Top Restaurants

Eden Seafood & Pizzeria

Eden Seafood & Pizzeria

8530 North Main Street, Eden, New York

Pizza Review

2 likes

716pieguy on One Bite Pizza App

716pieguy

5/19/25 8:55 PM

The gentleman and myself have returned. A long 17 months later and it’s hurt my soul every day for 17 months. Word on the street went from everyone wondering where is Batman to where are the real buffalo pizza critics. (Not that absolute fraud “BuffaloPizzaGuy. Pansy.) Anyways. Pizza time. This place scared me by reviews but upon this slice approaching me and giving it a taste, I enjoyed the sweetness of the sauce and the crispiness of the pepperoni. Good amount of cheese but also a bit bland overall. Better than the 4.0 originally given for sure

Pizza Review

bofapizza5/19/25, 8:52 p.m.

4.4

Not much flavor to this pizza at all. Pretty much only taste the pepperoni. I’d be disappointed if this was the only pizza place I could ever eat from if that has any meaning to you. Don’t want to harp on this place too much, it’s not bad. But nowhere near good. I mean nowhere. First review with the syndicate in a year so glad to be back out here. Puts a smile on my face after winning a round and scarfing down some pizza.

Pizza Review

casualpizzaconnoisseur5/19/25, 8:52 p.m.

5.1

Best way to put this is “I mean it’s alright like”-EDP. Nothing sticks out about this slice, the sauce is eh, and it just all around is just ok. Not much to bash about it, would probably taste good after swimming in a pool but besides that I’m not overly impressed.

Pizza Review

josh.allen175/13/21, 12:59 a.m.

0.9

Pizza Review

buffalopizzaguy10/7/19, 4:56 p.m.

6.5

Seafood and pizza are not mutually exclusive... Until you come here... Crust is nice and crispy, not exactly crispy on the bottom but not super floppy, either. The sauce is on the sweet side and the pepperoni is nice and crispy without being overcooked. This is a thicker slice but overall it’s average at best.

Pizza Review

justin.c10/5/18, 10:29 p.m.

4.7