El Paisano

One Round slice 7.8 One square slice 6.5 Good PIZZA

Good slice good service clean place 8.1 slice

Above average Buffalo slice with a crispy undercarriage. I like that they put blue cheese on the size.

Best grandma pie!

Good Solid Slice. Had slice of round and square. I prefer the round. Solid Good Pizza

Good pie. Thin crust. No flop.

What a light pizza with super crisp crust. Baked fresh. Not prevailed like most places . Good quality cheese and great sauce. Ate so many slices because it was like air. This stillwell was a hit!

It’s not Rosa’s from Queens but think we found our new spot for Sicilian here in Jersey. Place smells like a fryer but the pizza is damn good. Guy threw in some free zeppoles too...bonus.

Very good slice. Enjoyed the sauce it was on sweeter side. Cheese was very good. Lightly cooked as i like. Will try again

The Stillwell at the Doughfather is really good. Sauce has lots of flavor . I would definitely come back again.

Better then average Buffalo.. Sicilian was good..

I went Hawaiian but the gold medal here is the plain grandmas pie... great service but this pizza is top notch... if you order from here grandmas pie is there best slice

Good grandma pie, a tad oily. But overall good pie, nice flavored sauce, good crunch, fresh mozzarella