ryan.rutherford8/15/20, 1:39 a.m.
If you’re wondering why this pizza is rated so high by the community, it’s because the reviews are littered with a bunch of bogus 10s & high 9s. I’m here to tell you this is not elite pizza; the scores are artificially inflated. This pie straddles a fine line between well done & overcooked. There’s nothing creamy about the cheese, no lava-like flow, just very hardened and greasy. The sauce and cheese do have a lot of tang though. Very solid flavor, just needs to be pulled from the oven a little sooner. The dough is somewhat thick & filling, very firm with a very crispy crust, obviously from the amount of time it spent in the oven. Nothing special though, this pizza is a dime a dozen. I’m giving it a 6.9 cause the rest of these b.s. high-rated reviews can go F themselves.
sapitodavinci3/8/20, 7:20 p.m.
This review is for the square ONLY. I have to say, this was a nice surprise. I haven’t been here in years. Back in the day, this was the after-Alpine spot before work. Nice amount of cheese, a light crust, but excellent taste.
young_elmah1/9/20, 2:54 a.m.
This is a great pizza! Great cheese great sauce great bread!!! There’s only 2 things I wish were better. The first is that the pizza is way too oily which leaves you with a sluggish feeling after. And the second is that the pizza is very salty. If you can get over those two things you have your self a great pizza
adems_world11/6/19, 12:45 a.m.
I've had it fresh before and it was a little better but I've orderd it delivery a few times and it's been undercooked.
ray.rivera10/15/19, 4:03 a.m.
*Large Cheese Pie Review* I had this pie delivered (not too far from where I was staying) so that most likely made a difference on this review. I ate 3 slices... - Pizza was warm - Large slices - Very cheesy (great quality cheese) - Very Oily - Very soggy and floppy with the exception of the crust - Sauce was good (when I was able to taste it) - All of the above being said it actually still has a pretty good flavor
48 views•0 likes
pizzapaarty7/13/19, 2:26 a.m.
Tasty sauce, good crisp perfect amount of cheese deserves a review from Dave very soon
ethunder7/2/19, 8:34 p.m.
Wanted to go higher because it is tasty.. but the cheese was sliding off and there is a lot of oil. I’ll be back for a redemption tour
tim.lin6/8/19, 9:16 p.m.
Great slice, this review is on the round slice. Crust is a bit more doughy than my liking. Cheese is great, not too oily and good tang from the sauce. Square slice was a bit tough to chew.
bob.omalley4/25/19, 10:44 p.m.
Not a rookie, this is a solid 10 , Phil and tony have the pizza of gods
efrain.modesto4/13/19, 7:29 p.m.
Up there for best single slice in ridge..great tasting sauce...the crust is extra crunchy...the pizza smell is exactly what anyone would expect...a bit on the oily side but a fuxking great slice
vincent.guiffredo3/4/19, 9:57 p.m.
Classic and by far the best square in bay ridge! The slices are great also!
greg.keely12/1/18, 2:47 a.m.
Wow. This one was good. Well done crust. Great tasting sauce. A little too greasy though.