Elm Hill is easily the worst pizza I’ve ever eaten. In the 25 years I’ve lived next to it I’ve never been satisfied and will always travel anywhere else
thejonathan12/21/19, 10:38 p.m.
Truly my favorite pizza place! Elm Hill is remarkable. I’m going to keep the pizza review honest though, while acknowledging the bias.
stephen.earley212/8/19, 6:22 p.m.
Very good pizza. You can't put it anywhere in the ballpark of the pizza you find in New Haven. I'll say a 6.8 probably higher if you order well done.
pizzaaficionado11/5/18, 12:05 a.m.
Pizza falls apart before it can even get in your mouth. Too much grease and the way they cut it (squares) makes it soupy. The taste is good and so is the crust however the messiness brings it down. The crust is a huge plus.
peter.hogan.9/21/18, 11:10 p.m.
delicious combo of spinach and bacon. sauce and cheese compliment each other. crunchy crust tops it off