Emelio's Restaurant

Pizza is very, very, good! Sauce and crust work well together. Toppings are generous. Salads are out of this world too!

It’s a damn good pie in a dive bar atmosphere. Huge fan of Columbus-style and tavern style pizza and this one hit everything needed to make a good pie. One of the best pies I’ve had in Columbus

Great undercarriage. No flop. Quality cheese. Place is very good.

Great sauce, slightly greasy. Very good taste.

A very pleasant experience, don’t know how I’ve missed this place after all these years . This is cracker thin crust which is very good, crispy and nice sauce flavor, good cheese taste. Luv the pep and sausage. Would have scored higher if not for the oiliness but I still loved it and ate an entire 12” pie without hesitation. Highly recommend this tavern style joint .

Thin, crispy, delicious

Great bar pie, crispy, cheesy, a little greasy.

Good pizza, not great, the grease was everywhere but the sauce and pepperoni were amazing great flavor and the edges and of the crust were good but everywhere else was greasy dough.

Yummy, nice crisp pepperoni

Unreal. Perfect sauce, awesome cheese and top tier crisp.

Fire

**One Corner, you know the drill** IMHO, best pizza in Columbus area. Great cheese, sauce has a kick, cracker thin and no flop. Bartender on Monday nights is great!

Crispy crust and love the pepperoni

Good snap but sauce lacks flavor. Not sure what the Pres saw here. 8s is wildly high.

Yup. Shots of pepperoni whisky in every cup

Great tavern style. Crispy crust and great flavor.

Good sauce but the cheese is average. Bread and crust were almost chewy and hard to pull a part when biting ? Got the 10 inch, cut very oddly

Not a fan of tavern style but place is really cool. Great prices

I was driving home on i-70 and ordered a 12" "all the way" pizza from emelio's. It has pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, and pepperoncini. I ordered it well done and it cost about $22. The crust was cooked perfectly, the sauce tasted great, green peppers were juicy, pepperoncinis were crispy. I think the only thing i'd change for next time is to get extra cheese. Overall it's a fantastic pizza for a good deal, from a small place in southwest columbus.

Went out of our way to give this a try, did not disappoint. Old school vibe, very friendly folks, patio seating and limited parking. Just getting into tavern style pies. Cracker crust, great tang in the sauce. Little squares of cheesy joy!

Really good, really crispy just a little bit greasy