Emilia's Pizzeria

Bland

Best pizza in California

More of a neopolitan to me than NY style, but a damn good pizza with nice crust. Just wish it had more cheese. Its a great pizza, I just prefer more of a standard NY style

Pretty underwhelming, coming from someone that’s eaten pizza all across NYC. No way this is above 9. Pretty bland, not enough sauce, not enough cheese…. shame June’s closed down, that was the best slice in the bay. For all the trouble one has to go through in order to get a pie at this place, imo not worth it.

Incredible Pizza and was actually easier than expected to land an order. Crust is amazing with a perfect very slight char. Great hold, light flop. Meats were delicious. The sauce was fantastic but fell just short of 9 territory. I did wish I had a bit more sauce. A strong 8.9

Dank

Yup.. i see why the score is so up there.. the sauce is just DIFFERENT.. u can taste the freshness.. the basil in it and fresh tomatos... it has just the right amount of cheese and the crust is perfectly charred and crispy... NINE THREE...

This is the best Pizza of my lifetime. I will travel to Berkeley for as long as Keith is in operation to eat his pizza. Like Dabo says, Best Is The Standard...and This is the best.

Absolutely delicious, crunchy, fresh, tangy and New Haven inspired. Perfect amount of char, great ingredients, truly the best East Coast style in the Bay!

This is my only recommendation for pizza in the east Bay Area. Everything else is trash. Keith does an incredible job for a one man business. The hours and ordering method is definitely non-traditional but if you’re able to secure an order it’s so worth it. The sauce and cheese are perfectly distributed and the crust has that perfect crunchy yet chewy feel. Overall, it’s amazing and the only viable spot to go when in the east bay.

Soppressata and Calabrian Chiles. Phenomenal pizza. Great proportions, very little flop. One man shop with care put into each pizza.