aj.labella12/13/21, 11:39 p.m.
Sicilian preferred to the traditional. Traditional a little bland but Sicilian has more flavor. Little too doughy and could be more well done on both. Status quo is fair here. Solid average pie all around
jkash4/13/21, 4:02 p.m.
Best slice of pizza you’ll ever have. Perfect cheese to sauce to dough ratio. Crispy yet doughy, cheesy yet saucy. Must eat it HOT.
tcorcoran3/5/21, 8:15 p.m.
Extremely greasy, flop like a basset hound’s ears, and an average taste. Definitely smelled better than it tasted, but I’m not TOO disappointed. Average LI Slice for the average LI guy.
nyapprovedpizza12/28/20, 1:50 p.m.
If you’re wearing a thin shirt or no bra BE CAREFUL! It is very cold in this place during the winter if you just order pizza and sit down. Your NIPPLES will get HARD. Anyway, the place doesn’t have a smooth operation. They need to figure out their processes with getting their orders, putting it in the oven, and giving it to the customer. After my third slice, I ordered another one and the guy at the register put my slice on top of the oven for an indefinite amount of time because he did not see me sitting at the table in front of him. However, they are very nice in this place. A little too nice. The one guy at the podium kept talking to my girlfriend whenever I got up. It made me feel emasculated and little. However, he was pretty cute so I’d rate him at a 8.3. For the pizza I start with the crust. The ratio at the end of the slice was just a little too much crust. It was perfectly crispy and had a charred flavor to it. It also had residual which I love. The bottom of the pizza was very very floppy and greasy. It was way too floppy and it lost its structural integrity very easily. The cheese to sauce ratio may be just a little too much cheese. It also created that soupy thing that happens when it’s too hot with too much cheese. It had a very hard time sticking to the floppy crust. However, with that being said... it was delicious. The cheese was fresh and the sauce tasted like it was made with love. I enjoyed the sauce so much that I ordered a marinara slice which just has sauce and no cheese. This is one of my favorite spots actually on Long Island. I do believe I just had a below average slice today compared to my other times here but they get one shot at it like everyone else. I recommend going to this place if you’re in the area. They just have some needed refinement for their processes.
thetopcridict_5410/12/19, 8:59 p.m.
Cheese is okay dough is to chewy but the sauce is very good the hint of basil does not do the pizza well and crust is burnt but pretty good pizza
modeseven5/29/19, 1:57 a.m.
Fancy Pizza.... Vodka Margarita Pie No crunch, ok flavor, a little light on the sauce, crust was regular.
william.wohlsen3/3/19, 6:54 p.m.
I'm gonna start this off the problems with the pizza. 1st, Super floppy. 2nd, crust not crispy enough. 3rd, cheese stuck to wax paper in box and now it looks like a mess. Besides that. The sauce has a nice Tang and is really good. The cheese is excellent. The crust is really good. If they had more of a crisp. This pizza would be a 9.2. but because it does suffer from some things. 8.1 Bonus: Upside down slice...great slice of pizza. 8.1 as well. Margarita: 4.2. burned and didn't have that same flavor.
aj.rapp1/15/19, 12:31 a.m.
Long Island pizza guyyy how you doin So Sicilian slice overall pretty good not enough crisp on the bottom to elevate it to the 8’s cheese was perfect but good score - not a rookie score
85 views•4 likes