Emilio's – Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Commack NY

Really Good Sauce. Overall great pizza

Thanks to scotti fingas for the inspo. The crust is a great prize at the end. Nothing special. Would have on a rare occasion

Heard the regular isn’t even worth it. Solid Sicilian, so fluffy u could take a nap on it.

Excellent Long Island Pizza. I wish I lived in the neighborhood, id be here every week.

Delivery. Arrived on the colder side. Had the grandma and original pies. Good undercarriage on the original, fresh ingredients, but didn’t have that “x factor” - taking off points for temperature. It’s good bar pizza but nothing to tell your friends about.

The food here is good. Come for the food and not the pizza. It's bland and doughy. The specialty pizza looks unappetizing to boot.

Incredible sauce

Sicilian preferred to the traditional. Traditional a little bland but Sicilian has more flavor. Little too doughy and could be more well done on both. Status quo is fair here. Solid average pie all around

Best slice of pizza you’ll ever have. Perfect cheese to sauce to dough ratio. Crispy yet doughy, cheesy yet saucy. Must eat it HOT.

VERY floppy, kinda of greasy, average slice all around

Extremely greasy, flop like a basset hound’s ears, and an average taste. Definitely smelled better than it tasted, but I’m not TOO disappointed. Average LI Slice for the average LI guy.

Very lava pizza today but still great pizza

Bad pizza and worse people

Sicilian is the best around

Cheese is okay dough is to chewy but the sauce is very good the hint of basil does not do the pizza well and crust is burnt but pretty good pizza

Much better than the regular slice