Emily: West Village

Get the burger instead of the pizza here. Pizza didn’t have much flavor and was a mess.

One bite, everyone knows the rules…

Great pizza. Especially like the sauce

Pepperoni pie was crispy and delicious! A nice change of pace from the usual NY style!

Tasty Detroit style pizza. It was almost like a pan pizza with a more caramelized crust. Outside of the crust, the dough was softer and pillowy. It’s a good change of pace when you get tired of NY style pizza. Good sauce and toppings, but honestly I’d rather get their burger over their pizza next time I go.

To be fair this is my first time doing Detroit style so I don't have a ton to compare to. I would say this is not my favorite style. Way to bready. That may not be a reflection on Emily's but just a general aversion to this style. It's just not my favorite so right off the bat that's going to lose some points. Also had the burger I'm not a pretzel and mustard guy so for me the burger was meh. If you're a pretzel and mustard guy you'd probably love this. But in a city where you're ranking burgers amongst the best in the world this one's middle I'd the road for me.

One bite everyone knows the rules. Pizza was actually good, but service and management couldn’t have been much worse. Bad experience and won’t go back. Foodie agrees

The MVP pie - vodka sauce, pesto and red sauce. Amazing Detroit style crisp!!!

Best detroit style pizza you can get in NYC

Great combo of flavors

Pizza sucked. Burger was a 8.6

So delicious. Different style of pizza but the reviews aren’t fair. This is an 8+ all day

the Luca - great crunchy crust , nice salty , zesty marinara. Buffalo Mozz was outstanding

Different, descent. Wouldn’t run back here for the pizza.

Too inconsistent in slices

Pizza tasted great, no complaints at all but... the beauty is in the burger. I would rate the burger a 9.7, we are talking world class. Do yourself the favor