Enrico's Pizza & Restaurant

Good sauce, a mountain of cheese hiding the pepperoni that had little flavor. The crust was less than desirable.

I’ve had this twice now. I want to really like it, but it’s just mediocre. Not much taste and crust is too crispy. Got the sausage and couldn’t even really taste it. Support local at least…

I want to love this place so bad. Such a good, old school vibe inside. Super greasy, crust undercooked. Have heard locals rave of this place but I must be missing something. Have given this place 2 chances and both times were the same.

Great under carriage, great toppings, sauce is very tasty, but edge of crust was a little too crisp.

I got the Pep, mushroom and sausage. Very good flavor. Very cheesy. Crust was pretty thick. It not doughy and had a nice crisp on the edge. First time there and I’ll definitely go back.

Toppings are ok, the crust is a little too crunchy, the sauce has an average taste to it.

Alright Frankie.... Solid pie. Crisp Pepperoni, Crunchy Crust, decent sauce to compliment. No complaints here.. Dave Portnoy would go 7.6 on this ✅ that’s a review.

Doughy crust and bland. It has some crunch but no flavor it could use some butter and/or garlic? It needs something.

Very solid pizza. Thicker crust under the hood but not so much on the end.

Good pizza, the sauce is the best part. Crust is a little to be desired.

One of the best, authentic pizzas in NW Columbus

Well done extra cheese and sausage

Good pizza, thicker dough if you like cheese you’ll like this pizza with great flavor.