Enrico's Pizza Islamorada

Solid slice in the keys.

Good sauce, good cheese, a little doughy, well done. Good pizza!

This is a NJ 7.2, but a Floridian 8.3. Great slice!

Good crust with medium thickness. slightly greasy, but all in a good quality package with quality cheese and toppings. Great spot, we drove 30 minutes for it, and it was worth the drive.

Gas station pizza. Rock hard crust greasy small.

More d than I thought. Just like my ex wife Karen was getting behind my back

Cheese had good flavor, but had a bit too much grease on it. Crust was too thin and was overcooked

It’s not bad, but I definitely prefer a thicker crust. The crust at the end had a burnt taste.

Besides the unorganized staff, the cheese was good but the crust tasted awful. I would have rated it much higher if the crust was good.

Solid Cheese, crust isn’t that great. Tons of flop. 7.6

Good cheese. No crust, good for a stop along the round pizza place.

Only thing keeping this out of the 8’s is my friend insisted on meat lovers garbage pizza not the gold medal slice. Straight cheese I might have gone higher loved the crust.

Crust was fantastic. Super crispy and ULTRA thin. I would love for them to tone down the herbs in the sauce a bit (could easily be a 9+ if they did), but otherwise, a super high quality pie and just as good as some of the best in NYC. Well done, especially for Florida.