Enzo’s Pizzeria of Garden City

5.0 at best tasteless pizza

Average at best. None of that classic sicilian bite to it. Cheese was fine, sauce was kinda bland. Very crunchy and flakey which i dont think of when i think of a good classic sicilian.

Variety of slices here. Had a regular and a grandma. Same score for both. Regular was loaded with cheese which lowered the score for me. Grandma I thought was cooked nicely but had a lot of garlic on it.

The regular grandma and the alla vodka grandma were solid, easy 7.8s but the star at Enzo’s is the gorgonzola & garlic slice! I’m not usually a fan of sliced w/o tomato sauce but this one is the best one I’ve ever had!!

Top tier pizza. Great flavor, good hold, fantastic crunch on crust.

Just average pizza, greasy

Meh. The regular slice was too floppy & sloppy by having too much cheese on a crust that couldn’t hold it. The grandma was a bit garlicky & I didn’t love the sauce. There’s much better pizza very close to this place.

Buffalo chicken slice

Really nice new pizzeria in Garden City! The pizza was pleasant but nothing really stood out. Looking forward to trying other things on the menu.

I know it's not a regular but it's most incredible slice I've ever eaten. A garlic gorgonzola slice. Nice thin crust just like the regular which is an 8.3