This is a pretty solid round pie. The cheese and sauce are pretty good and there isn't much of a flop. The crust is fluffy and thick which adds to the overall score in my opinion. Just a good option for pizza with a small wait time.
thekillerpanda9/16/23, 11:03 p.m.
I got the Cacio a Pepe (sp?) But it was really good. crust was very good
mike.whelan9/3/23, 10:19 p.m.
Sauce is incredible. Perfect amount of cheese. Crust had a great crisp crunch to it. An absolute must have!
sam.kahane7/28/23, 12:57 a.m.
Dough and crust were great. Sicilian was a little too much dough though. I’m not a huge fan of the sauce / cheese ribbon coverage on the triangle - I like consistency
pizzamike57/19/23, 9:11 p.m.
This was a solid pizza!!! Well worth the one hour train ride from Queens to Brooklyn. Would have been in the 9’s if it was a little more crispy
godofthunder397/8/23, 6:25 p.m.
Great slice. Perfect amount of cheese. Dough is really tasty. Nice crispness. Excellent.
duncan.lundy6/12/23, 7:08 p.m.
Regular was very thin, cooked well but not crispy until the crust. The Sicilian was different from any I ever had; the crust was simultaneously heavy and also light and fluffy. Incredible.
evan.raphael4/15/23, 10:15 p.m.
A very dough forward slice. While the slices were thin, the bitterness of the sourdough was a very prominent part of the flavor profile. The regular slice gets a rating of 8 well the specialty slice which had Calabrian chilies, onion, and orange honey receives like an 8.3
margaritaman4/12/23, 4:18 p.m.
Really good pizza; Better than the picture shows. Superrrr thin on the regular slice, can see what other people were saying with the Sicilian being a little bread-y. Needed a little more cheese. Overall 8.3.
colin.obrien3/18/23, 7:44 p.m.
Thinny thin, excellent crunch, beautiful sauce, tasty cheese, but just a little greasy, almost perfection. Nice clerk. Chill area to hang in the back
phillypizzaman3/10/23, 12:00 a.m.
Review 378. Nice slice bet a whole pie is better. Thin slice no flop no grease. Decent crisp. Flavorful sauce. Average cheese. The crust was disappointing I had higher hopes. Wasn’t bad just thought would have crisp to it that’s all
wadezzeria11/20/22, 12:12 a.m.
Nice char on the slice reheat… curious to try a whole pie next time… regular was better than sicilian
nicky_eats11/12/22, 7:34 p.m.
Dave was a little high with this place. 8.7? Maybe he was a lot of high..
tarik.bazzy11/11/22, 6:51 p.m.
Overrated . Not better than Joe's an 8.7 from Dave is an abomination still a good slice. But I've had better pizza at Sicilys in Detroit than here