I agree with the many over Dave on this one. Solid slice.. dough is really good, that’s definitely the best part. Overall flavor is good.. The Sicilian has to be the weirdest Sicilian I’ve ever had. I don’t know if I caught a weird slice, but it was 99% bread with some sauce on jt.. couldn’t taste the cheese really… it looked thinly glued on.. I don’t know how to describe it. It was like good bread you would eat when they place bread on your table at a restaurant… but it didn’t feel like pizza. Odd. That got a 7.2 for me… in other words, as good as it looks, get the regular. Or maybe I got a weird one… orrrr it’s just wasn’t my thing… I’ll never know 😂
thekillerpanda9/16/23, 11:03 p.m.
I got the Cacio a Pepe (sp?) But it was really good. crust was very good
mike.whelan9/3/23, 10:19 p.m.
Sauce is incredible. Perfect amount of cheese. Crust had a great crisp crunch to it. An absolute must have!
sam.kahane7/28/23, 12:57 a.m.
Dough and crust were great. Sicilian was a little too much dough though. I’m not a huge fan of the sauce / cheese ribbon coverage on the triangle - I like consistency
pizzamike57/19/23, 9:11 p.m.
This was a solid pizza!!! Well worth the one hour train ride from Queens to Brooklyn. Would have been in the 9’s if it was a little more crispy
godofthunder397/8/23, 6:25 p.m.
Great slice. Perfect amount of cheese. Dough is really tasty. Nice crispness. Excellent.
duncan.lundy6/12/23, 7:08 p.m.
Regular was very thin, cooked well but not crispy until the crust. The Sicilian was different from any I ever had; the crust was simultaneously heavy and also light and fluffy. Incredible.
evan.raphael4/15/23, 10:15 p.m.
A very dough forward slice. While the slices were thin, the bitterness of the sourdough was a very prominent part of the flavor profile. The regular slice gets a rating of 8 well the specialty slice which had Calabrian chilies, onion, and orange honey receives like an 8.3
margaritaman4/12/23, 4:18 p.m.
Really good pizza; Better than the picture shows. Superrrr thin on the regular slice, can see what other people were saying with the Sicilian being a little bread-y. Needed a little more cheese. Overall 8.3.
colin.obrien3/18/23, 7:44 p.m.
Thinny thin, excellent crunch, beautiful sauce, tasty cheese, but just a little greasy, almost perfection. Nice clerk. Chill area to hang in the back
phillypizzaman3/10/23, 12:00 a.m.
Review 378. Nice slice bet a whole pie is better. Thin slice no flop no grease. Decent crisp. Flavorful sauce. Average cheese. The crust was disappointing I had higher hopes. Wasn’t bad just thought would have crisp to it that’s all
will.ketelsen12/17/22, 10:06 p.m.
This is a pretty solid round pie. The cheese and sauce are pretty good and there isn't much of a flop. The crust is fluffy and thick which adds to the overall score in my opinion. Just a good option for pizza with a small wait time.
wadezzeria11/20/22, 12:12 a.m.
Nice char on the slice reheat… curious to try a whole pie next time… regular was better than sicilian
nicky_eats11/12/22, 7:34 p.m.
Dave was a little high with this place. 8.7? Maybe he was a lot of high..
tarik.bazzy11/11/22, 6:51 p.m.
Overrated . Not better than Joe's an 8.7 from Dave is an abomination still a good slice. But I've had better pizza at Sicilys in Detroit than here