Good crust and bottom, but cheese underdone. Peculiar reheated taste. $4.40 price is too high for average slice.
b..fleischman9/5/19, 4:10 p.m.
No flop, no grease, nice and thin, good cheese and sauce. Great slice
vincent.armetta7/28/19, 11:51 p.m.
Really really good slice. Go with the normal round. I do not think this is best Sicilian in New York. Normal slice definitely better.
shapsandrew7/14/19, 4:23 p.m.
Meh...cheese wasn’t great crust was doughey. Don’t know what Dave was eating
ky.wh6/26/19, 5:33 p.m.
Really good flavors and good textures. Not too greasy and just the right ratios. Bonus review on the Margherita, the tomatoes were great, the cheese was a little flat but it all worked together well.
misha.korolev5/31/19, 8:00 p.m.
maybe the best pizza i’ve ever had. try the buffalo chicken pizza
tyler.t15/16/19, 12:23 a.m.
Place has a high review from the Prez so I had to stop by. This place is a lil more pricey than Joes and other pizzerias. $3.75 vs standard $3 price. Crust was good and slice is packed full of cheese but....this slice was burnt and everytime I took a bite - I can taste the burnt dough. Would have Joes or Johns of Bleecker anyday of the week.
mauriciomaxmoncayo4/21/19, 10:17 p.m.
Somewhat crunchy, very cheesy with great taste, ratio cheese:sauce good, a little greasy, not wow’ed but very solid slice. Manhattan beats Brooklyn’s Finest Compost easily.
20 views•1 like