Famous Ben's Pizza

Good cheese, no flop, tangy sauce, solid slice

Good crust and bottom, but cheese underdone. Peculiar reheated taste. $4.40 price is too high for average slice.

8.5 for the pepperoni. It was great. The Margherita was pretty good but pepperoni worth going back for

Last time I had a Sicilian for lunch was when I got into a bar fight with some kids from North Jersey. Excellent crust, good cheese, good sauce. Altogether a very good, if not great, slice.

pepperoni

Solid

A very solid slice of pizza. No flop, well done undercarriage. The sauce has a little sweetness, edge on the cheese but it has enough dough to hold it together and give it a good balance. Do a doubleheader and get the Sicilian that’s an 8.1 !!

Good solid slice. Could have been a little warmer. Great sauce.

The homemade sauce made it one of the tastiest pizzas I’ve ever had and it had no flop.

A little too much sauce but still amazing

Okay pizza, has a good crunch but the sauce taste like nothing.

This place was nominated “Best Sicilian in the City” so I had to try it. Crust was quite good with a nice crunch - tasted fresh. Sauce more on the sweet side, but works well with the cheese. Is the best Sicilian in NYC? No, but it’s quite good.

Great spot !!!!!!

Got into the 8’s, but not quite with the greats

Sicilian - good crisp, underwhelming cheese.

Sauce is good, crust is great!

So most times pizza sauce and pasta sauce are different. This was def last sauce on pizza. Was fucking weird.