As a former CT resident.... and pizza expert.... THIS IS IT!!! The best Ah-beetz in Florida. Loved every bite. Great sauce, crisp, cheese and char. No flop.
erick.horne5/8/22, 8:16 p.m.
Lucky enough to have this in my backyard. I agree with Dave though on this one. Great slice with good crunch and sauce. The grease is a little heavy but overall a solid pizza.
luke.huculak3/23/22, 9:52 p.m.
Not too bad, cheese and sauce have good taste. Crust could be better, very floppy. It was also some of the greasiest pizza I’ve ever seen. The sausage has a decent taste to it.
trhea12/9/22, 1:16 a.m.
Some of the best pizza in Florida. Not quite the original like in New Haven, but definitely good.
david.griffin12/28/21, 8:55 p.m.
Amazing, true authentic new haven style pizza. I travel all over the country for work. This is for sure at the very top of the list out of anywhere I’ve had, including new haven and NYC. It’s just perfect.
rich.takmajian12/3/21, 2:33 a.m.
Probably one of the best pizzas I’ve eaten in 58 years of eating pizzas! Love New Haven pizza! Great combination of sauce, toppings, and a light crunchy crust! Loved the family atmosphere too! Great owners
joe.fetter10/20/21, 7:18 p.m.
This is legitimately New Haven style pizza. This is not just great pizza for Florida, but just as good as any pizza in the pizza capital of the world- New Haven, CT.
tequestahead10/12/21, 2:42 a.m.
I hope I didn’t underscore this pizza as anything in the 8s is excellent and I am probably merely leaving room to go higher if I find something better down the road. Not likely in south Florida. Great sauce, crisp, chew with no flop and the staff in particular Christopher are great. Definitely drive for this pie and cannot wait to be back. As Spicoli once said, “Awesome, Totally Awesome!” Great undercarriage Frankie. That’s a review.
danielle.coryn9/24/21, 12:51 a.m.
Pictures will just not do this pizza justice. My expertise in new Haven Style apizza began long ago, as I spent many years in New Haven and made countless trips to Pepe’s (and Sally’s). Fantini’s pizza is the closest to Pepe’s since I left the are. There is absolutely no comparison to any pizza place in a 100 mile radius, let alone all of Florida. If you like a true New Haven style apizza, be sure to ask for it well done. The whole thing is an absolute experience. From the warm & friendly family vibes as you walk inside, to the perfect amount of sweetness in the sauce. When the pizza comes out, let it sit a moment, so you don’t burn your face off. Take in the sights and aroma of the apizz. Once you take that first bite, and sink your teeth through the top notch mozz and finally hit that crunch… you’ll know. You’ll know you made it to heaven. Dave is truly doing himself an injustice if he doesn’t give this place a shot.
joe.r188/22/21, 12:15 a.m.
Very tasty pie, good sauce, crisp crust, staff is top notch, definitely a travel pie
b.karolchyk6/20/21, 9:35 p.m.
WOW! I was stuck between an 8.9 and 9.1. Dave would LOVE this place. Exceptional crisp and amazing taste. Such a nice little spot. Definitely the best pizza in this area of Florida. You won’t find anything better for hundreds of miles. Coming from New Jersey/New York area, this will be my new spot for years to come. Awesome! 8.9.
dvilla12184/11/21, 12:58 p.m.
I was told New Haven pizza is the way to go, so I had to try this place. Rumor was, it’s better than Regina. Well, it wasn’t. That doesn’t mean it was bad. The ricotta and meatball was good but the plain cheese was a little bland. I’m willing to give it another try if I’m in the area again. BTW the waitstaff was exceptional. and Santarpio’s remains alone in the “better than Regina” category.
buchemist4/10/21, 10:40 p.m.
Burnt large cheese. Also ordered 2 pepperoni slices through Slice - got cheese. It’s a pattern
nyistheonlypizza4/7/21, 9:49 p.m.
A new pizza joint about 2 years old. The best crust in Martin County, with a thin undercarriage with a beautiful burn. The sauce is made with San Marizano tomatoes which is top of the line and the cheese is great quality with good spices.
shagman4/4/21, 2:47 a.m.
Great taste! Wow, best sauce I’ve had in So Flo to date. Flavorful cheese as well. Happy to find this place on the app. The only thing keeping it out of the 8’s is the crust. It tasted great with good undercarriage and outer end crispiness, but it was a little too thick and very chewy ...though I actually kinda liked the chewiness. To be fair it’s my first known New Haven style pizza, so maybe I’m just not accustomed to it. Very good pizza that was a little too heavy for me to say it’s in the 8’s at this time, but it’s definitely worth trying. That a review.
david.thrasher3/8/21, 10:05 p.m.
Being from Boston, Florida has some of the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Fantini’s is an exception. Very good quality pizza if you’re looking for traditional pizza. The best I’ve had so far in Stuart.