Big a** slices which at first glance looked like some flop was coming our way. But no, it had a neutral Colorado flop. Crust had strong crisp and goes well with the good ratio of cheese to sauce. Flavor of sauce is king of this slice. Highly recommend.
travisbubser2/23/21, 7:58 p.m.
Don’t be fooled, this ain’t NY pizza. Good stuff considering what’s around tho
jim.joynt2/1/20, 11:56 p.m.
My Wife is a little dilutional. Pizza slices are big and tasty. I give this pizza a 6.9. Not bad and service was great. Busy place during lunch and dinner.
15 views•1 like
landen.klaber10/16/19, 10:31 p.m.
Got the big ass slice with some banana peppers and bacon. When it got to me there was tons of flop (and if I’m being honest made me kind of hesitant) but once get a taste of the sauce and the crispy crust it opens you mind a little bit. This size is awesome for the price and the employees that work there are super friendly. They also have this biscuit place inside that’s better than the pizza.
voodooslice9/15/19, 8:49 p.m.
Fat Sully's is an average pie. Nothing really caught my attention in the taste department. Not much char on the crust. Cheese was alright. Sauce didn't give my taste buds anything to be excited about.
mister.mo7/21/19, 1:27 a.m.
More sauce and this is mid 7s no doubt but missing that flavor so staying in the 6s but a high one. Good slice.
nick.visocky6/19/19, 1:13 a.m.
good size for the price, but not crunchy enough. the crust was super crisp and very good, but it was a bit greasy and the sauce wasn’t as good as i was hoping for. overall good solid slice. 6.8 that’s the review.
justinsilver5/31/19, 6:44 p.m.
Good tang. Not a lot of flop. Good balance of sauce and cheese. Could have been cooked a bit better. Sizable slice for $3.50. 7.5/10. Solid pizza.