ncpizzalover4/3/21, 11:20 a.m.
Solid pie... coming from the east coast l didn’t know what to expect when it came to Colorado pizza. Pleasantly surprised with Fat Sully’s. Extremely impressed with the thin crust which had good under carriage char and crunch. Good sauce and cheese. (Went back a second time, perhaps got them at a busier hour as pie was slightly undercooked... mildly disappointed) score would be higher if second pie was as cooked as good as first... will be back at a future time and will definitely come back.
citizen_rich10/3/20, 8:00 p.m.
I had higher hopes honestly. Even though I read that they make 26” pizzas I wasn’t aware that they ONLY make 26” pizzas. They do offer by the slice ordering though. That being said, I wanted a whole pie for leftovers. I guess 26” is a bit bigger than I imagined. Anyway, the sauce is the best part of this pizza; it has a nice tomato flavor without being just one note. I ordered my pie with pepperoni, sausage and banana peppers. Nobody says you have to only order plain, that’s the Prez’s arena. The meats were spicy, the crust had a fairly decent crunchy/chewy/burnt bits flavor but it wasn’t terribly flavorful, kinda dull. Because the pie is so big, the inner circle (about the size of a normal medium or large sized pizza) was all doughy/chewy mush. The “outer half ring” was much more pleasant with both soft and chewy bites spicy/tomato/cheese flavors mixed with some crunch. I had heard this is one of the best pizzas in Colorado Springs, maybe so but it’s not worthy of anything close to an 8.
amy.sanchez9/7/20, 2:40 a.m.
Best pizza in the Springs. Generous slices, thin, crispy with great sauce and cheese. Love these slices and open late. Love, love, love Fat Sully’s. Our go-to.
ben.vogel8/25/20, 9:12 p.m.
Pretty classic New York pizza. Whole lotta New York flop. Cheese absorbed by sauce, doesn’t add a ton of flavor. Nothing special, but solid overall
j.lafo8/1/20, 3:36 a.m.
It was big, tasted good, and was cooked perfectly. Not life changing but a really good pie.
12elevencatering7/12/20, 4:46 a.m.
26” pie slices bigger than my 2 hands. Excellent. They also have GF
zeke.ballinger7/5/20, 11:33 p.m.
Great flavor, no crunch, little floppy, a bit too much grease for my liking
quiksnap2/5/20, 10:26 p.m.
Excellent bar pie, some of the most elite I've had in the state, in fact. Super thin, super floppy, they put the cheese on top of the peps. Greasy, not horribly so. Cheese could be better quality. Less flop would bump it up to at least the high 7's. I would probably ask for it to be well done next time, the crisp of the next day was fantastic. GOOD PRICE, 20 dollar pie, literally cannot beat that.
jack.murdock11/6/19, 7:12 a.m.
Second time having it, liked it better the first time. Definitely one of the better Colorado Springs slices, no doubt. A very large and crispy slice, however maybe a little too crispy for my liking. Not a lot of sauce which makes the taste pretty bland. Overall, one of the best in the Springs but a little too “dry” and burnt.
hispizzab10/5/19, 4:00 p.m.
I feel like I’ve tried a lot of the pizza here in the springs. And a lot of it is the same. Needless to say, this place is different. The crust is crispy with a slight char. And the cheese.....the cheese 👌🏼 And my first time ordering a pie, I came a little early. They bumped us up so we didn’t have to wait as long. Great service! Easily my new favorite pizza.
gregory.rose10/5/19, 3:47 p.m.
Hands down the best pizza I’ve had since New York.. also the closest thing to a Manhattan slice I’ve had in the springs. Make sure to only get cheese!
tony129/2/19, 2:26 p.m.
Huge slice. Pretty good. I liked how thin it was with a crispy crust. A little greasy though.
tom.blaney8/31/19, 1:54 a.m.
Ok, screwed up on the original review. This crust is paper thin and crispy. I love it. Sauce is tangy and the toppings are great. I’m leaning into the 8’s for this place. I’m from Chicago, so it’s completely different style. It is very good. 8.3