Fat Sully's Pizza

Big slice for the price. Paper thin, good undercarriage, crispy, right cheese / sauce ratio. Chewy crust could use a bit more crisp. Little bit of char on the bottom.

Pizza was good, nothing special. Saw some reviews saying to get well done and I would agree. This score may have been better with it well done. The Garlic Knots were excellent though.

Crust had a nice crunch

Great local pizza that beats anything I have back home. Worth getting if you’re around one.

One bite everybody knows the rules!!! 8.8 Excellent pizza 🍕 ordered a ex large sausage and it was bigger than our table 🤣 would highly recommend! Get it well done almost burnt so its not floppy and a side of chipotle ranch to dip the crust 🤤🤤 amazing

Always one of my favorites yes always a little floppy cause it’s so thin and big but always crisp

Great solid pizza!

Big New York style slices with a huge amount of flop. The flavor wasn't actually that bad but the grease was overwhelming and dripping from the slice. Crust was thin and fine, but could have been a little crispier. OneBiteEveryBodyKnowsTheRules

Great char, a big flop,but that being said I liked the flavor, pretty fucking good!

Delicious slices and super cheap. Next time asking for extra sauce.

Got a cheese slice. It’s pretty well cooked. And very good. Maybe just a little to burned but definitely earned its 7.4 on here.

Nothing left. Crunchy crust, great sauce, and I recommend the chipotle ranch. Solid 8

not a lot of flop, not to greasy, and i like w here there were going with the crunch on the crust but didn’t quit reach that crispy crunch were all a sucker for and that’s why fat sullys is just shy of being with the gods.

Nice thin New York slice. Crispy crust and great flavor.

Wayy to much flop. Absolutely no crunch in the crust. Flavor was great. If they cooked it in the proper oven it would be in the 7s

Great price, huge picture, fun atmosphere. Pizza could be crispier, yet the sauce is great!

Sometimes it feels like Denver only offers hipster, over priced average pies. Finally found a place that reminds me of the east coast. Solid pizza that’s a good bang for your buck. Denver 7.1 but a New York 6.5

Thin, crisp, affordable and a good cheese to sauce ratio. Great crust!

Hot n ready.. floppy, no flavor