Top Restaurants

Faye's Pizza

1821 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan, WI

Pizza Review

1 like

shadowrage20 on One Bite Pizza App

shadowrage20

6/29/21 1:31 AM

Looks can be deceiving. Definitely overrated. Cheese was the consistency of a frozen pizza that is thick but wasn’t cooked long enough. Some of the slices undercarriage were crispy and some were mildly doughy. Sauce was the only thing this pie had going for it. Just seemed half-ass even though it was only our order baking . Maybe I got a dud but everybody knows the rules…

Pizza Review

sleepytimejarvis11/13/24, 6:26 p.m.

8.6

I may be biased tavern style pizza being from the Midwest, but these guys knock it out of the park everytime. It’s so modestly priced, absolutely killer cheese and local toppings, and just a perfect crisp and corn meal covered undercarriage. If you’re in Sheboygan, this is a must. My favorite pizza back home.

Pizza Review

jackmcmahon6/16/22, 12:45 a.m.

7.5

Great Chicago tavern style pizza. I grew up on the southwest side of Chicago and I can tell you Fayes can stand up against most all of them…..except for Veto & Nicks. Been coming up to Sheboygan for 16 years now. Make it to Fayes at least once every time we are and here and they never disappoint.

Pizza Review

dan.diener3/22/21, 4:47 p.m.

8.5

Pizza Review

walden_hiker1/30/21, 6:26 p.m.

7.1

Pizza Review

andrew.verhulst7/6/19, 2:00 a.m.

6.8

Good solid pizza, can’t go wrong

Pizza Review

scott.lemke5/24/19, 12:11 a.m.

5.2

Looked and smelled really good but was lacking the flavor. Cheese was hard Hard and crust was dry. Heard really good things on this place and was disappointed in the end.

robby.brown4/21/19, 2:34 a.m.

8.4

84 views•0 likes