petezahpi2/20/23, 7:05 p.m.
Individual meatball & garlic. Very thin crust. Even thinner than tomato pies! Very good! The large pies looked even better
lennoll11/25/23, 11:26 p.m.
Posting a rare Review Update as today’s in-restaurant pie was a significant upgrade from the pandemic takeout experience in 2021. Definitely one of the best Bar Pies I’ve enjoyed to date. Crispy thin crust was able to bear a full share of cheesy saucy topping without crumbling like Matzo. Even handled a sausage mushroom pie well. Yum.
oppadaddy00710/22/22, 2:05 p.m.
The crisp and cheese were on point. The sauce was a bit bland for me and the crust reminded me of matzah. All in all, a solid thin-crust, bar pie if you are ever in or near Freehold.
stephan.salay10/1/22, 1:46 a.m.
The Prez right on point with the 8.8 score! Perfect thinny e thin cracker crust. This one here was sausage and mushroom. We also got the plain. A must get to place. Great atmosphere. Typical old school nj pizza. In ending, can we stop giving reviews on pizza huts, and chain pizzas. What a waste…….
whatispizza59/18/22, 10:03 p.m.
Finally got here after 37 years . Stunning bar pie. Copious crunch. A little bit heavy on the grease is the only critique stopping this from a colossal scores.
neil.tortorelli9/1/22, 4:54 p.m.
Solid bar pie. Love the crunch. Would love a little more done-ness on the cheese
paul.redd8/13/22, 12:21 a.m.
Amazing pizza we loved it. it wasn’t just the pizza but the appetizers to for example the mozz sticks and French fries were great.over all the meal was amazing!👍🏻🍟🍕😃😃😃😃😃🤯🤯🤯
jmontyandlindabird7/24/22, 10:07 p.m.
Bear in mind, if you are really hungry you might need to get more than one pie because they are paper thin. It’s well balanced and a pizza that is uniquely its own, even compared to other bar pizzas.
manny.montalvo7/12/22, 1:05 p.m.
I was in the area and decided to try this place out! The pizza was super thin crust and it was piping hot. No flop at all and great undercarriage. The chesse had a different taste that anything else I ever had. In my opinion I rather have a bit more crust and more classic tasting cheese. But the restaurant was beautiful