Awesome pizza! Definitely better than Cape Cod Cafe.
wrxsti875/17/22, 4:53 p.m.
This is a Pizza worth traveling for one of the best in Jersey. The crust is crispy has a bit of cornmeal in. the sauce hasa nice tang to it and a nice low moisture cheese.
howsdasauce3/20/22, 9:27 p.m.
Good pizza. No flop sauce good cheese good. Very thin wafer style crust.
johnnykong1293/16/22, 5:59 p.m.
A cash only pizzeria and a staple in downtown Freehold. This was a nice bar pizza with a very good cracker thin crispy crust. Very light and easy to eat. This is the protocol Barstool Dave type of pizza (rated 8.8 a few years ago). I'm more a traditionalist but still enjoyed this pie to a tune of 8.2
nick.mauro3/4/22, 8:15 p.m.
It’s been a minute since my last review. I’ve been on the Keto diet and having success so haven’t been eating Pizza. But it’s my birthday weekend, we’re headed down the shore so, found a spot worth trying. Super thinny thin and light. The sauce was sweet and light and well seasoned. Well balanced. The cheese was delightfully cheesy. A quality mozzarella. This was a top notch pie. Could house for days if my stomach didn’t shrink lol.
rich.carlson1/2/22, 2:15 p.m.
Family style old skool pizza and Italian restaurant. Every pizza is thin crust and the plain is the best in New Jersey. Our table shared the plain, sausage, bacon and onion, eggplant and white pizza. Literally everyone loved it. I had a classic chicken Parmagian with a pasta side and the red sauce is also spectacular. Go here. Go often. They have been here for 100 years ! Note- cash only. Bottled beer, no drafts.
jack.tron12/8/21, 6:50 p.m.
I called back for hot pepper and the Mexican guy said they don’t have any, I said ok that’s alright and he just hung up on me
7 views•0 likes
bigdickslices11/27/21, 10:54 p.m.
Been here before as a kid, but this is my visit post-Portnoy’s experience. Wafer thin crust, great crisp and a delicious sauce. Personally i don’t prefer thin crust, but i understand the hype and Federici’s does not disappoint.
michael.cavuoto111/14/21, 4:50 a.m.
Definitely one of the best pies I have had, drove about 45 minutes and it was worth all my time line was pretty long but with just a party of two we got seated immediately parking was a big issue. Overall Pizza was absolutely amazing thin crust great cheese great sauce absolutely deserves a nine flat. Also the homemade mozzarella sticks are absolutely amazing you have to try them
g_man29211/6/21, 8:15 p.m.
Crust was nice and thin. Also had some char not a lot. Was easy to control did not have a lot of flop. Tasted great. Definitely recommend if you are a fan of thin crust pizza!
pizzapixels11/6/21, 8:12 p.m.
So good that we ate the whole thing IN THE CAR! 🤪 out of the three of us one gave it a 7, one gave it a 7.8 and an 8.5. The sauce has hints of red wine in it so it is a very savory not sweet sauce. Crust was super thin. The thinnest I have ever had. It was a bit greasy but it’s pizza! The undercarriage could have been a bit crispier. Worth the hour drove to try it!
amanda.anwander10/27/21, 2:59 a.m.
Solid cracker crust pizza. Pretty greasy but good flavor and sauce to cheese ratio.