Having family in Freehold for over 30 years, I can't believe today was the first time I ever ate from here. Well, better late than never. Decided to gift the fam with a gift certificate since it's one of their favorite go-to establishments. While on the GS Parkway, about thirty minutes away, I called my lunch order in, along with the gift certificates. A very pleasant young lady let me know that it would be ready in about 15 minutes, and that I would be taken care of via curbside pickup. I had a feeling it would be ready prior to my arrival, which is totally okay because I find that the pizza tastes best after it's cooled off just a tad. That was exactly the case. Perfect temperature. Face wasn't burned off . Sauce: balanced; just enough; not too little/much Cheese: evenly melted and browned; very few bubbles, not greasy; makes a perfect teammate with the sauce and crust Crust and Undercarriage Unique, crispy, slightly flakey; it's almost like a toasted, flakey, cracker ; guarantee it's different and unique for every pie; "No two crusts are alike at Federici's," it's imperfect and that's what I loved about it; well-done just as I had asked; Thank you I drove an hour from Hudson County. This is Destination-Pizza. This is the real deal. My new standard. 9.1
marlborom2c4/6/21, 8:25 p.m.
Thin.crispy,lite, this is good pizza. I enjoyed it, and the staff very cool. So heres the scoop, if you enjoy the Jersey thin crust this is the quintessential pie. Sauce is ok, but not as flavorful as say diFara's in Brooklyn. Still if in the area its a nice snack. The food is good too.
pizza-dan3/28/21, 7:44 p.m.
I was in the area for a family gathering and I wanted to check this place out. Very thin and crispy bar pie. Good flavor. I’m think the Prez was a little off on this one. I’m saying 7.8, not 8.8 like he thought.
chris.jf073/25/21, 2:05 a.m.
Great bar style pizza! The pizza is thin, made well-done, flavorful, and crispy. Also, the restaurant has a nice old school vibe.
kgupta8223/14/21, 3:57 a.m.
Cheese to sauce in a perfect ratio for us. The only complaint was it was super greasy but omg the pizza was amazing
robert.eis3/13/21, 4:29 a.m.
Yes thinny thin crust. Crispy, check. A bit greasy though. A little more flavorful sauce and substance and this would be eights
lennoll13/9/21, 5:22 p.m.
This place is legendary for their classic Bar Pies.... the style of which I’m not a big fan. In this category, anything over 6.5 is quite good in my book.
erlil2/27/21, 12:30 a.m.
RLLY RLLY GOOD BAR PIZZA THIN AND GREAT CRUST thanks michael for being best boyfriend
ryan.ogor2/25/21, 8:21 p.m.
Delicious. Super thin and crispy. I ate 4 slices myself. Great atmosphere and very polite staff.
jonathan.franke2/16/21, 9:59 p.m.
Really good thin crust pizza!!! Reminds me of home back in NY...would def go back again!!!”
jason.borrelli2/16/21, 3:20 a.m.
My son and I visited after a youth hockey game with another father and son. We do not live in the area and made a special trip as we frequently visit highly rated Barstool Pizza review establishments. The restaurant is a traditional family restaurant with 100 year history according to the website. We specifically came for the thin crust pizza. It looked good and my son took the first slice. It was an endless string of cheese and very greasy. It tasted very bland, very floppy so much so I took a slice of sausage and all the cheese and sausage fell off on to another slice. Then the hour and fifteen drive home I had relentless indigestion. I must say David Portnoy of Barstool Sports clearly missed the mark or had a completely different pizza then we had. I have a relative who lives in Freehold and asked about the restaurant before visiting and they said the restaurant is overrated. If you are in the area may I suggest Brooklyn Square with 3 locations or Pete & Elda’s. That’s a review