Fierro's Pizza

Real Solid Pizza. Great Sauce, and Undercarriage! Always quality at this location.

Just your typical New York style. Whole lot of flop. Sauce is great. Has a nice tang. No crunch on the bit and a little too much cheese. High 6 could possibly creep into the low 7s.

BEST SPOT! This is the real deal OG PLACE. So reliable so yummy, family owned. And they sell chocolate bars. Love love this place and the people

good undercarriage, decent taste, lacking in tomato sauce flavor. but overall a good pie to order for takeout super enjoyable

One bite. Some know, some don’t. A little flop a little grease. If ur hungry it works, if not, ehh

Pretty solid and doughy

Phenomenal crust, really great cheese. Perfect pizza for the rainy day on your vacation. Only improvement would be a more balanced cheese-sauce ratio

Long-established joint. A little greasy, but flavorful. Definitely one of the top pizza places in East Hampton. Could have been a 7.9. Went with 8.1 because I’ve had it many times over the last 20 years and they have not changed the recipe one bit. Points for consistency.

A little bit greasy, good crunchy crust

A little too greasy on the pepperoni slice. Crispy crust. Could’ve had more cheese. Friendly staff. Brooklyn attitude in the Hamptons. Cool spot.