Fierro’s Pizza Montauk

Under cooked not impressed

This rating is only for the plain slice, but it’s kind of a trio with pesto. Anyways, legit amazing. It’s garlic heavy. Good amount of sauce with a lot of tang. It was crispy. I ordered it well done and I suggest you do too. The ratings on this place are low. This is a great slice. Fuck the haters.

W Montualk slice place is class new name every year Same quality #makedlussogreatagain🇺🇸

Nice slice all around, great crust, nice cheese, nice sauce, nice job. Excellent staff, very friendly, great customer service.

Classic football with pizza minimal flop. Decent flavor however the sauce could use a little extra kick. Solid beach pizza.

May have over scored this one but pretty average slice here in Montauk. Nothing good about it.

Pretty average slice, little cheesy but it gets the job done.

Convenient being next to Montauk Brewing. It will get you filled up but it’s not outstanding.