Finelli NY Pizzeria

Pretty good pizza. Cooked right. Dough was a tad saltier than my preference but I’m not too salty about it. Sauce was really good. Cheese was a little scarce. Solid place overall

Thin, crispy crust, excellent sauce, a good amount of cheese and toppings. Overall a very good pizza and the best pie I’ve had in Maine. It’s a little out of my way, but I look forward to getting back here to try the sandwiches.

Phenomenal, I would suggest the charred crust, it’s crispy and light.

Good crisp. Cheese and sauce held it back from getting into the sevens.

We’re touring New England. Went to New Haven and did Sally’s Apizza, Pepe’s, and others. Got to Maine and found Finelli’s. Tell them you’re a big One Bite Portnoy fan and they know what to do. Thin, crispy, nice charred crust, zero flop, great under carriage. You won’t be disappointed. We were lucky to find.

Nice undercarriage with good char. Cheese sauce ratio was on point and tangy. Crisp was top notch and no flop whatsoever. Best pizza in Maine hands down

Never disappoints the sauce to cheese ratio is always on point my favorite spot and I think best spot in the state

Great crust, sauce has good tomato flavor, no flop! Reminds me of NJ pizza more than NY. Best in the area!

Not quite plaque worthy, but a good solid slice. Good crust and sauce. Cheese was probably what held this out of the 8’s

Not bad, not good. If you’re really craving pizza, this will do it, but I wouldn’t recommend it. I like it pretty crispy but it was very charred on the bottom. Cheese and sauce were very underwhelming. You might like this if you’re in a pizza pinch and realllly need a slice no matter what the cost. Also you would like this if the other 3 pizza places you wanted to go to in the area were closed and this was the only option. It’s a 5.4 for me.

Perfect slice. Great crunch and flavor

Perfect crust and delicious pizza

Cold slice :(

Not bad at all. Why did the pictures keep getting cut off on this app?

Tasty pizza with good quality ingredients. I think my biggest complaint is that the dough was a bit tough and that it was quite salty. Good tasting sauce and cheese though and overall I do recommend!

Great tasting margarita pizza, with a fantastic charred crust...could have used a bit more basil

This one gets the captains score. Drive 25 just to get it

Crispy, cheesy and delicious.

One of the best slices in Maine. Incredibly thin crispy dough, excellent sauce. However I believe they have switched to a lower quality cheese recently.