Fini Pizza Amagansett

Excellent pizza. The tomato pie was the best

Has two days in a row. Day 1: 8.8. Optimal crunch. Day two: 7.1. Suboptimal crunch.

Fini this pizza in my mouth

Not to heavy and has fresh tomato sauce

Lebron Approves great crust good sauce

I asked for pepperoni pizza and they put one piece of pepperoni. Maybe next time I say pepperonis please pepperonis pizza

Nice thin crust. Good undercarriage, with no grease. Quite tasty!

I loved it. Especially the sauce… and it’s light which I also love. Dough, fantastic. Will be back. And the staff is chill, if that matters :-)

Really good slice. Unbelievable crust/crisp and flavor. A must try.

Fini out in the Hamptons. Still have to get to the one in Williamsburg. Good quality slices here. The cheese and seasoning were the big selling point on all the slices. They could’ve heated my slices up a bit more which did impact my scores. My score is for the regular. Had a nice cheese blend on a well done slice. Outer crust could have been a bit softer for my preference. Really curious if the Brooklyn spot has softer dough. The white slice was definitely the most unique of the bunch. I scored it a 7.8. They squeezed lemon juice on top which I feel is gonna be a new trend for white slices because it was a great touch on the slice. Lastly was the ‘just sauce’ slice which had a heavy dusting of what seemed to be garlic powder but it did have some heat on it so I could be wrong. It was a 7.6.

A great overall slice and experience. Wonderful undercarriage… like top 20. Perfect combination of sauce and mozzarella. Hot as balls. Fresh when I went, around noon.

Very Good

Odd mix of Neapolitan and New York slice. Great dough. Sauce needs work

White 8.2 Grandma 7.5 Sicilian 5.1 awful sauce dry crust The slice here are $5.50 which would be fine b considering the location but they are all really small slices

Just a hair below Brooklyn but still a great slice

Very good pizza more crispy than I expected. Was a very good slice great sauce would definitely recommend. Also a cool green box adds to it