Forest Avenue Pizza

I love this place family run old-school Italian pizza

My favorite pizza & my kids favorite pizza too pizza is so good. You can’t only get one slice.

I love this place 🍕

In my opinion, one of the best pizzerias on Long Island

My two favorite slices 🍕 And I feel like the quality got better under new management

Great slice

Heard that they’re under new management and the food got so much better absolutely amazing!!

Probably the best barbecue slice ever had cooked perfectly and the white slice was amazing

It was good. I’d say this is a reliable spot for a good slice. Cheese could be better.

Giant slice, crust could be a little more crisp, good flavor needs a little bit more sauce tho. Not bad but not great

The ziti slice is the best in the city. Solid Sicilian pie as well. The regular slice is solid but never my first choice.

Really good solid pizza ! Cheesy and perfectly cooked ! What a slice !!!! Very good .

Big slice, thin and crispy with a bit of flop. Cheese is delicious, but personally a little more sauce would be good. Worth a trip for some good pizza.

This is the remnants. Way to oily. It was so thin it didn’t even hold up to a slice. And it was probably left over from yesterday because it was early after they opened.

Super oily, thin yet incredibly doughy, sub average sauce. Not my style of pizza.

The pizza was pretty greasy. There was also a little bit too much cheese to sauce ratio. Crust started out crispy, but since it was so greasy, it turned soggy after a few minutes. Now you may be wondering why Peter's graceful face has made it's presence known. The reason being is that the grease on this pizza tasted like nut sweat.

Very good, Thin crust Neopolitan style. Decent flop very little grease.

Yes it’s grandma style pizza, and yes I’m biased about this place being that it is my hometown original, literally raised on this pizza place from when it was still across the street. My pride & joy pizza 👌🏻

Best thin slice, low oil, crispy bottom dough that snaps when you bite in.

Not the worst slice I’ve had. Only good thing really was the dough. Sauce was like water and a ton of cheese.

Good but I like more sauce if you like little sauce this place is for you. Grandma slice was a 7.6.