About Formaggio's Pie Shack
24 Yelp Reviews
gary.cooper49/9/20, 1:15 p.m.
Frommagio’s lives up the name with the mountain of delicious cheese on their signature deep dish pizza. The sauce was a highlight as well with both its abundance and fresh tang. Lots of pepperoni and bacon to suite your carnivorous cravings. Very filling and heavy, but also quite tasty. $40 for a medium makes it hard to justify on a regular basis. I’d order this again but looking forward to try their thin crust next time.
ratemypie8/15/20, 6:40 p.m.
Great Pizza! When opening the pizza it looked great. Smell was good. The crust and cheese are really good. The sauce is were its at. Very tomatoie. Almost every great pizza place has a unique sauce and is crucial IMO. Not the best I've had, but I will definitely be a repeat customer. A big 8.0 score.
mike.g19855/3/20, 10:41 p.m.
Zero crisp. None. Only thing missing. Sauce was great and generous on the cheese. With toppings had plenty of crunch. Wish it was there fully.
chrisknox8/29/19, 11:34 a.m.
Wow. Great tasting pizza. Liked the sweet sauce. This is just a large deep dish pepperoni cheese Pizza. The guy said it’s over 5 lbs. he was not kidding. I could only eat once slice. Great pizza and guy who made it was amazing talking too.
amurr5/1/19, 10:40 p.m.
Had Formaggios one time and it was one of the better pizzas I’ve ever had, got the deep dish with half pepperoni cause I like a classic and pie and the waitress suggested the Canadian on the other half with bacon pepperoni and mushroom and I have to say she was not wrong, the Canadian surpassed my expectations by a long shot, great crust with thick cheese, would of rated it higher if it wasn’t for the toppings being below the layer of cheese, pepperoni was not crispy at all but the other facets of the pizza were so overwhelming I could overlook the fact I got soft pepperonis in the middle, none the less it is an amazing pizza and the Canadian was definitely all time
ryev2212/31/18, 10:55 p.m.
First review, not a pizza rookie! The Shack is a place I’ve been meaning to review ever since I discovered this amazing app. Had the spicy sauce, that I had today, has a good kick and some heat on the back end. It’s not oppressive, but adds a nice “how do you do”... the regular sauce has a nice garlic tang that one would expect from any quality homemade pizza sauce. The toppings are plentiful and the cheese, as the name of the Shack suggests, is never ending. Best part is that despite of the huge cheese pulls, it’s not greasy! Crust is flavourful and crisp and has a nice flop. Don’t admire it too long or you may lose a few toppings. Can’t recommend this place enough! I’ll review a deep dish next time, but needless to say ALL of my Chicago friends prefer The Shack’s deep dish over Giordanos and Lou Malnati’s... if you don’t know those names, delete the app. That’s the review.