Forno's

Crust had great crunch, no flop, good sauce, no undercarriage

I was starving, if the picture didn't make it obvious. Anyway, here's the review. The plain slice on the right had a yummy sauce in my opinion and the cheese was fine. The sauce has Nonna's sweetness without Nonna's flop. Score 7.8 The BBQ chicken sauce in the middle was the best of the bunch, a great amount of chicken and the BBQ sauce was tangy and sweet, just as I like it. Score 8.8 The Philly Cheesesteak slice on the left had a ton of cheeses on it, the peppers and onions gave good flavor and the steak was good, just wish there was more steak on it. Score 8.2 This is Peekskill's best in my opinion, and I think this clears all the Peekskill places to review.

Nice and thin but still doughy, could be cooked longer, a little too sloppy and greasy. Average score for an average slice.

After eating a small pizza at Baci’s, I had a slice at Avellino’s, a slice at Forno’s, and a slice and Antonio’s—definitely the best slice of the three individual slices. God was I pizza’s out. So why the best of theee? First, the rust was nicely done with light charring, it had moderately tangy sauce, it had better than average sauce to cheese ratio, which I didn’t expect. Also you get a big slice, and it was the cheapest slice of the three spots. Issue with the slice, as others have said, is in the construction of it. The slice nearly tore away from the undercarriage, mine wasn’t exceptional cheesy, but the weight of the grease made a sloppy mess of me. One of the better places in the immediate area. But not that exceptional that’s it’s worth going out of the way for.

Crust was enjoyable, more then enough cheese. Solid 6.5

Dough, crust, and cheese were great. Solid sauce but way to much of it. They also used WAY too much cheese which made it crack like a cracker. Better application would boost the score.

Great crunch on the bite, gods amount of cheese and the sauce is good too. Could be a little tighter tho. We gotta get a Dave here

Best slice in NY. When I come to town I have to stop at Fornos. It doesn't matter what slice you get it's all REAL NY Pizza. Dave has to come here and Review this pizza.

“Margarita Slice” - The picture shows it all.... what’s going on here the Slice is COLD!

Gigantic flop. That’s as far as the review went. I tried to pick it up then the 14 pounds of cheese said no. There is easily enough mozzarella on this for 4 slices. What a shame. The sauce was very good and the dough & crust are light and crispy. If I were able to eat this slice it would be one of the best in Peekskill and could easily touch the 8.0 tier.

Blown away. Great pizza. First time in Peekskill. I think I'm making a good choice about possibly moving here. Slice is great. Good tang. Crunchy crust. Lots of cheese. Love it. Keep it up!

Very very solid. I’m an out of towner and used the app to find this place. I like a little thicker crust, which held the score back, but a very good slice of pizza 👌🏼

Not my style with too much cheese but still a decent slice.

Won’t find a better buff chic slice. Consistency is key. Great all around pizza

Chicken Parm Pizza is off the chain! Can’t go wrong with ordering here! It’s close to home so we usually order once or twice a week!

Probably the best pizza in Peekskill. It’s not gonna blow your mind.

The chicken bacon ranch is pure awesome from here! (Those are half slices in the pic)