27 views•0 likes
alexgross75/13/22, 10:49 p.m.
Wasn’t impressed at all. It was just decent. Sauce cheese crust all just average at best. Expected a lot more. I know this isn’t the original in New Haven, but Sally’s blew this away.
jcconrad4/10/22, 5:55 p.m.
Great pie, little bit of flop but excellent flavor. Wanted to give an 8.0 but I’m not a rookie, Pepe’s gets the benefit of the doubt. Little girl table next to me crying cause there was too much cheese on a pie????
mike-p11/6/21, 2:32 p.m.
Good crust, thin and crunchy, not overly greasy, very good sauce. Pricey at the Casino, but thats expected. I'm going 7.4
paulfrommontauk10/15/21, 10:32 p.m.
When a slice gets an 8.8 after traveling from Mohegan Sun to Montauk & is reheated the next day you know the pie is special
7 views•0 likes
melissa.sikora12/7/20, 9:13 p.m.
Yes im Giving it a 10 Because I know there is nothing better. There will be no other pizza that I ever try that will be better than this so it's getting my 10. Cant say enough, had modern apizza friday night and now Pepes on Monday. Pepes wins.
cmr62110/3/20, 10:33 p.m.
Solid New Haven style A-Pizza. Nice crisp Minimal flop. Good taste A little greasy. Overall awesome
papajahn7/1/20, 8:24 p.m.
Floppy and hot as fuck but it lives up to the New Haven hype. The crust is top tier and the sauce is mind blowing.
jorge.carreiro3/9/20, 7:04 p.m.
One of the best pizzas I have had in North America. Very little flop, sauce is good but the best part is the thin crunchy crust. Delicious