Milestone evening. Made the pilgrimage to “the best pizza joint in the US”. Hands down the best pizza I have ever had. This knocks a bucket lister off the slate. Met a couple from Florida, New Jersey, and a single gentleman from Boston all who travelled in just for the pizza. One of the couples owned their own pizza place in NJ and Pepe’s is the only pizza place he or his family have eaten other than their own for 10 years. Pouring down rain and an hour wait while there were 27 people ahead of me getting soaked. Worth every second. Thankful to get to experience it all
bearking7210/18/21, 3:24 a.m.
Not much to offer here. Little sauce. Good char crust so so cheese was good quality. Over all for a bucket list pizza destination ,no big celebration.
thedaydreamer10/17/21, 8:52 p.m.
I had the white clam pizza. Great pizza! The amount of cheese was perfect. The end tasted like a burnt cracker.
mark.genco10/15/21, 10:26 p.m.
Great crust, nice char and a good crisp. Sauce is zesty, but pizza was a bit greasy, especially the half that was just cheese. Oddly the side with pepperoni and cherry peppers was less greasy. Definitely worth the stop. Will try Sally’s or Modern next time I am in town.
patrick.oneill110/14/21, 1:56 a.m.
Only 8.5 was the cream soda. Not the best crust or cheese. Actually Poor quality cheese, flavorless sauce.
john.wlasuk10/10/21, 1:33 a.m.
Crunchy crust, sauce and cheese combo strong. First time at New Haven location - a step above their other locations.
r_leggs10/8/21, 12:05 p.m.
Crust was out of this world. Perfection! The sauce is tasty and the cheese is good. Very good pie.
mr.pepperoni110/1/21, 9:18 p.m.
These place was the best I ever had it had all the right flavors with the trip from any were in a 2 hour radius it is crispy and fluffy at the same time would come again.
piz-czar10/1/21, 9:06 p.m.
Absolutely Fantastic. Worth the trip from Westchester NY!!! Getting a pie to take home!
kyle.varanyak10/1/21, 1:38 a.m.
Its not the pizza capital just stop it. Lucky Im being nice with this score
thurston.howell iii9/28/21, 10:44 p.m.
Perfect dough and char, homemade bacon, fresh clams. OG of apizza
john.harrop9/19/21, 12:45 a.m.
Original is better than the off shoots, but not much, tied with angelos on 57th street for my favorite for the best