This pains me to write this because I had high expectations. Iām from Brooklyn, and I think Brooklyn has the best pizza. But I donāt look down on other places like New Haven. But this was a disgraciad. Ice cold pie and they didnāt even cut the fucking thing. If I sent ppl from New Haven to the best pizzerias in Brooklyn and they treated them like this, I would hope theyād have good building insurance. If you are in New Haven for pizza, I would skip Frank Pepeās and head over to one of the other overrated pizzerias. Or drive another hour and half and head to Brooklyn weāre a pie is hot and actually cut properly.
