jeanie.riggs3/12/21, 10:22 p.m.
The thin chewy crust was everything! Sweet tomato sauce, fresh cut pepperoni and silky mozzarella cheese. The coal fire oven gave a great tasting char to the edges. Nicely priced at $10.50 for a small.
1derekabenson3/8/21, 5:36 a.m.
I've eaten here 20+ times. Not my favorite pie in the country, but Pepe's undoubtedly sets the standard for traditional coal fired pie.
chora3/1/21, 1:45 a.m.
Great pizza. Worth the trip from Jersey for the hype behind New Haven pizza.
adammjensen2/28/21, 9:34 p.m.
Solid, slightly overrated. Found cheese a little bland and not enough sauce to my liking for a higher score
robert.andrew12/28/21, 6:21 p.m.
Nice crust and cheese, sauce tastes a bit more acidic to me, compared to their neighbors, because of the fresh tomato, but solid pie
evenmartins2/27/21, 10:22 p.m.
This is our favorite pizza in the Country. Great quality ingredients, we always get the pepperoni (which are also great quality, not the mass produced pre-packaged stuff the mediocre places use). Plenty of cheese, pepperoni, AND sauce. Another thing mediocre places get wrong, there is no sauce on them, they put a little on and it cooks off leaving you with cheese and bread, missing ⅓ of the key ingredient. Not at this place and this location, their first / original location (We did have that problem at their Yonkers location once). They are famous for their white cheese and clam but we hated it, too dry, so we are only rating it for the plain and the pepperoni.
daniellatorresx2/27/21, 6:48 a.m.
Picture does not do this pizza justice. This and the Delorenzo, Robbinsville NJ pie is hard to compete for second fav pizza. Amazing
anthony.cruz12/27/21, 3:44 a.m.
Forgot to take a photo, but it was delicious. Traveled from western mass for it, do not regret it.
dylan.scuderi2/23/21, 10:04 p.m.
Really really pizza. A lil grease and every slice after got slightly worse but first score is the only one that counts. Follow my pizza review IG: Scoobapizza
35 views•2 likes
mike_h.nyc2/19/21, 11:33 p.m.
perfect crust very good cheese a little greasy and solid cheese cut differently but it works out
pave.dortnoy32/17/21, 1:46 a.m.
Great pizZa. Nice and crunchy crust, tasty cheese, and tangy sauce.
pizzavore2/16/21, 11:18 p.m.
Large cheese pizza, 2:45pm on a Tuesday Pros: Delicious char flavor in the undercarriage found in every bite. Great tasting sauce and cheese, burnt crust is fantastic Cons: No complaints for Frank Verdict: One of the best, only a small handful of places are better than Frank Pepe in New Haven
jack.homola2/15/21, 9:40 p.m.
Great slice, very nice crust and great cheese, decent sauce, but lacking in quantity. Would definitely recommend this to someone going to new haven
mike.aim2/12/21, 1:14 a.m.
Great crust. Wasn't feeling the sauce at all. It's like sweet, but like a flat sweet.
foodiggity2/12/21, 12:41 a.m.
Pepes a little bit of everything that makes New Haven pizza great... best coal flavor of the bunch, great texture.
daveyb2/7/21, 1:02 p.m.
Burn your face off hot! Really good crust, little flop but the cheese and sauce were great.