seth.dietz6/19/21, 12:57 a.m.
I like the amount of cheese better than Sally's, but the overall bake on Sally's was superior.
alexandra.marchuk6/17/21, 3:56 p.m.
Sorry, I forgot to take a picture but the pie wasn’t round at all and they cut it in super weird rectangular pieces and normal triangles but very thin that you couldn’t even hold it. The menu is very poor with toppings and sausage pizza is terrible. The actual place is also very uncomfortable. They also burnt pizza a bit and the waiting time was pretty long. If you like a good actual New York pizza you don’t want to go there
benjamin.segal6/13/21, 8:47 p.m.
K one bite everybody knows the rules! Tomato Pie FAR SUPERIOR to the Mozzarella - Tomato Pie 8.5 and Mozzarella 7.2 - both good but if you’re comin here - it’s the Tomato Pie hands down!
scherrthing6/12/21, 3:56 p.m.
Cheese pizza topping was great. Crust not as hard as the tomato pie which was the best crust. White clam pie was excellent
subdiver6/9/21, 11:46 p.m.
The best in New Haven so far beating Modern and Sally’s over all. Their regular pie (8.5) has good sauce and cheese on a partly charred crust. Their clam pie is even better (8.9) with big chunks of meat with tasty sauce.
chris.pacia6/9/21, 5:34 p.m.
This was very good. Thin crust with great crisp. Minimal flop. Hard to find anything to knock. Maybe the cheese could have been a little more flavorful.
ringosghost6/5/21, 6:00 a.m.
Took the family on a Pizza field trip. First stop Frank Pepes. Great Pizza, Great Pizza Joint, Perfect char, flavorful sauce. Family loved it. I had business in New Haven 2 years back. The person there said New Haven is known for their pizza. Being an arrogant NYer my whole life, I gave him a glare that said “you are an idiot” I tamed it up because of my business. Well, finally got here and this review is my apology to him. 9.1 to Frank Pepe
kevin_h6/1/21, 11:25 p.m.
I gave the Yonkers location a 9.2 ... I have to give the original location a 9.3 Right ? ...pure perfection
pizzaqueen075/30/21, 8:05 p.m.
To me, it was just average. Nothing to rave about. The cheese was different from anything I’ve ever tasted.. and not in the greatest way.
yeore5/28/21, 9:26 p.m.
Way more chewy than expected. Can taste coal fire but didn’t strike me as anything special. However, I think my order was sitting for a bit and thus wasn’t very hot.
tastingadventure5/21/21, 10:31 p.m.
Tasty! A little bit of a flop .. meatball slices are great!
boston.sauce5/19/21, 9:23 p.m.
1 tomato pie add mozzarella, pepperoni, extra sauce, not cut everyone knows the rules
dpriz545/17/21, 5:08 p.m.
Coal fired New haven style. Everything about this pizza is amazing. This is the Pepe’s you go to not the others.
cj.ivor5/16/21, 10:00 p.m.
Washed down with a Foxon Park Gassosa soda. A true New Haven experience. 🇮🇹🥤 Coal fired goodness. Crust was perfection. The best crust of all the pies we've had down here. Garlic and salty. Sauce and cheese were above average, great but not spectacular. Quality pie, no doubt about it. Glad to be able to enjoy inside." 🚫😷 ❤🍕
jc6685/14/21, 11:32 p.m.
Brilliant. Everything was top notch. Cheese was great, sauce was great, dough was super crunchy, no flop everything that makes a great pizza, it had. The only thing I would suggest is making the crust a bit less crunchy. Personally I like my crust softer,but that is just personal preference overall this pizza was great.