rex9/25/20, 11:50 p.m.
Great pie. Margarita and sausage take the win over cheese. Crust phenomenal.
mitch.gurevich9/13/20, 9:32 p.m.
Tried the Fairfield version but this one was definitely a better time. The sauce and crust definitely beat out Modern. Have to come back for Sally’s and Bar.
danny.roses9/12/20, 2:26 p.m.
Great pizza. Only con half the crust was burnt to hell. I do love a good crisp but this was left in the oven a bit too long. Besides that...a great pie
bud.bulgogi9/8/20, 3:30 a.m.
Pack your bags and gas up the car, it is well worth the trip. It may end up being the best pizza you ever eat.
justinsilver9/6/20, 6:24 p.m.
You like swimming? How about swimming in a pool of oil? That’s what this pizza was. Overall...sauce: good, but nothing to write home about. Cheese: fine but oily AF. Crust: split decision, I said it was meh, GF said she enjoyed the chewyness. Wouldn’t travel far for this, but ok if you’re in the area. ADDITIONALLY, the white clam earns a 6.0: clam tasted too fishy, not enough flavor from the white sauce, and VERY uneven distribution of the clams. Glad I tried, but would not try again.
matthew.jennett9/1/20, 5:00 p.m.
Great. Just great. No complaints. Crust was cooked perfectly. Cheese and sauce was perfectly balanced. Good flop.
bryan.falco8/30/20, 8:17 p.m.
Classic pizza. Almost can’t get better. Great cheese, perfect crust, lot of bubbles. Good crisp, good char. Cooked perfectly. Love it!
steven.h8/26/20, 4:55 p.m.
Was very excited to try the best votes pizza in Connecticut but wasn’t thrilled with the pizza personally I would rather the one from Waterbury.
kristen.duva8/22/20, 9:30 p.m.
This coal fire crust is fire (ha)! Ranks 3rd out of the 4 New Haven spots for me, but still better than almost every pizza I’ve had in the past. Also tried the white clam pizza - I don’t like clams but had to try it because of recommendations and it didn’t disappoint!
halez4ever8/19/20, 1:38 a.m.
Pretty good but i felt there was too much cheese and not enough tang in the sauce
ian.frons8/16/20, 1:11 p.m.
1st review. We screwed up the timing so were probably 10+ minutes late on the pick up. This caused major flop and some cool down. I’ve had Pepe’s before and know it’s damn well better than an 8.2. Also reviewed the tomato pie at a 9.2 even with it not being fresh. Darby gave it a 10. Average of 9.1. Pepe’s is truly an excellent pizza experience.
25 views•3 likes