Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

It was easier to chew rubber than this pizza! What happened to Frank Pepe’s?

Love Pepe’s. Every. Thing. About. It.

I’ve been to multiple Pepe’s locations and this one is top tier. I normally tend to go for a doughier typed pizza rather than something thin and crunchy but this one definitely got the job done. One thing I really like about their pizza is how every slice is different. One slice could have some rich tasting cheese, another might be filled with great sauce and you might grab another one with some 10/10 pepperoni. The only thing keeping this pizza from being perfect is the crunchy black crust whereas I usually like it nice and doughy.

Frank Pepe’s is all hype. I came here expecting the holy grail of life changing pizzas, the ark of the covenant of pizzas if you will, and was sorely disappointed. It was just kind of meh. Not the worst pizza I’ve ever had, but definitely not what it’s cracked up to be.

This is the second Pepe’s I’ve tried besides the original on Wooster St. It was good but doesn’t compare to Wooster St.. The undercarriage was light. There was some crunch but overall under cooked. Again, the pizza was good by Hartford area standards but the bar is high when Frank Pepe’s name is on the signage.

Not as good as the original in New Haven

Ordered the pep and red pepper well done. The ‘za had good taste, crispy crust and a good undercarriage. We prefer this place over the New Haven location. Don’t sleep on the tiramisu, 8.8

Half Doppio Pep and half Tomato pie. Very good. Pep side savory with a touch of spice, tomato side sweet, fresh and clean. Still the New Haven location Reigns supreme but do recommend for sure.

🐐

OutFuckingStanding pie!!! This is how pizzas should be made 🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻

It did not disappoint. It was near perfect.

Fresh tomato pie with fresh grated mozzarella on top

Crust is the best I have ever tasted. Sauce had a nice garlic and olive oil pop to it. Highly addictive

Haven’t had Frank Pepe’s in a couple of years. Revisiting this slice is absolutely amazing. Sweet sauce, great cheese, crispy crust. Slight flop, but amazing regardless.

Cheese is 9.1 Marg is 9.9

Good.... but not so great!

Revising an earlier review of this location. While maybe still just a bit short of the flagship location, WH Pepes has consistently churned out really good pies any time I went over the past year.

Always fantastic, easily the best pizza I've ever had each time I go. Would rate about the same as their other locations.