Freddie & Pepper's

Great amount of cheese. Crust has great crunch. Solid slice. Worth traveling for if in NY, but not going out of the way for

Regular cheese slice. A little above average. Cheese is strong sauce is okay doesn’t stand out.

Solid 8. Crust was perfect. No grease. Decent flop not too much. Great flavor. Sauce was solid and the seasoning was unmatched

Solid slice. Good sauce and plenty of it that almost tastes like it was made with fresh tomatoes. Would’ve been a higher score but no crunch at all and a little on the doughy side

Lots of grease and pretty floppy, but the marinara on this is pretty good. Wouldn’t put it in the 8’s, more of a standard slice. That’s a review Franklyn!

Nice crisp, little bit of flop, minimal grease, excellent cheese, balanced sauce! Classic taste of a slice from your youth! Only missing a nice crust bubble!

Crusty crust and good cheese consistency

Really good crust! The one on the bottom was SUPER spicy! I’d try any of their pizzas!

Good pizza, very fresh hearty pizza with lots of choices.

Very fresh.

A surprisingly good slice. It’s slightly thick and fluffy. The sauce is really delicious and the cheese is good too. Worth trying out if you’re in the area.

Great pizza, good crisp on bottom, definitely one of the better I’ve had in city. Lacked on the sauce a little bit. Overall great pizza, great people.

Thick and crunchy slice, good sauce, good cheese. If the crust to sauce and cheese ratio was more balanced, this could easily be in the 8’s.

Undercooked and doughy, too much flop standards went way down hill

This pizza had so much oil I coulda done an oil change on my car. Cheese was thick and you had to chew it 100 times per bite so you don’t choke to death on it. No crisp on the crust.

Tried a few places in New York, including some higher rates slices. Freddie and peppers is by far the best!! Back for my third visit. The crunch of the base mixed with the amazing flavours make it a winning combo!