I’ve had this pizza many times. And many times it’s been in the 8’s. Not tonight. Better than your average slice but not the best slice I’ve had here.
Order now on Slice
Order Freddie & Pepper's
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
rushfan-duhpizzareviewdude4/24/22, 5:02 p.m.
Above average pizza. Too much cheese. Excellent crust. Whatever. For a fairly highly rated joint it ain’t all that.
anthony.pizza312/19/21, 1:23 a.m.
Doesn’t look like much BUT feels like it’s going to taste good the moment you touch it, they heated it up just right and the taste is explosive!
brooklyngreg12/18/21, 11:24 p.m.
Great taste. Amazing crust. A little bit too much cheese though.
d-pizza11/7/21, 7:05 p.m.
This is not good. Very greasy, with doughy, floppy crust. The sauce is not fresh tasting, and it overall reminded me of the school lunch pizza I was served in the sixth grade. Not sure how it’s this highly rated.
kevin_h9/25/21, 9:23 p.m.
VERY GOOD slice... nice crust, sauce, lots of cheese...very good NYC slice
ryan.rutherford9/25/21, 7:15 p.m.
This is what I call a “Broadway Pie.” At $21, this is high-end theater district prices for dollar slice quality pizza. Thick, doughy and soft…it has all the attributes of a dollar slice. The sauce has decent flavor, somewhat zesty but extremely acidic. Typical dollar slice textured cheese, a semi-creamy melted blend just a tad above generic. The crust is slightly crispy, but not enough to make up for the overall softness of the entire pizza. The difference between a whole pie and a slice is enormous. A slice is reheated, generating a “fake crisp,” which faked out Portnoy into giving this an 8.1; but a whole pie comes out fresh and much softer. It’s not bad but definitely not worth going out of your way for as that inflated score would suggest. Don’t be fooled by this expensive pizza with cheap ingredients.
krausschapman6/10/21, 4:48 p.m.
Great crispy crust. Little greasy and would prefer more sauce to cheese ratio but a solid slice!
fartsicie6/10/21, 12:01 a.m.
Flop was amazing. Great freaking cheese. Amazing crust. Did find myself looking for sauce though with all the cheese. Fantastic fucking slice though.
pizzainmyface4/10/21, 7:02 p.m.
Perfect cheese and great crunch! Light on the sauce but overall, loved it. Can’t wait to slam a pie on a football Sunday.
gmpizza4/5/21, 9:16 p.m.
I literally do not know what the other reviews are saying. It has cheese but that’s about it. Sauce taste good but not even close to enough for the thickness of the crust and the amount of cheese. Reminded me of a doughy frozen pizza