Freddie & Pepper's

Super solid slice!

Better than what most people think but wouldn’t say I’d travel 30 mins for. Good pizza light on sauce crisp undercarriage.

Good cheese, decent sauce, nice crust which is thicker then thin crust but thinner than football pies.

Pretty good but kinda greasy

Not terrible, but not the best.

Slice was solid NY Pizza. Good undercarriage. The best part of this small place was the service by what I believe to be the owner. Great respect for his customers.

This pizza was great all around but not enough sauce. Best crunch I’ve ever had

Pretty weak cheese. Needs more salt content. Had to add salt to wake this slice up. Didn’t do much. Crust is passionless. Sauce is very, very sour. Street concrete after taste. Won’t need to return. 7.0 just wouldn’t be fair.

Good cheese. Appearance was awesome. This place has tons of options for vegans and a variety of flavors. Authentic place to check out

crisp crust, gooey cheese, needs more mushroom

Good slices but have a wow factor. Lots of different choices in their display case. Gonna give it slightly lower score that Portnoy here. 7.5 Place is located on the back side of the legendary Beacon Theater.

Watery sauce

Slice was delicious. Really good crisp. Score could have been higher, but little grease on top.

No margarita so cheese it is… good dough, good crust enjoyed it more than Joe’s. 7.1

Last stop on my Upper West Side pizza walk. I’m not usually one to judge Dave’s ratings but he missed on this one. Place is in a neat location but the slice was what I used to get in my college dorm food court. Only thing getting it above a 6 was the dough was cooked nicely. Slice barely had any sauce and the cheese tasted generic.