3,122 views•72 likes
sean.mcdonnell33/7/21, 11:02 p.m.
I asked for a cheese slice and a Sicilian and got a Grandma slice instead of the cheese slice — hey, no big deal. Generally not a Grandma fan, but this one was pretty good. Sauce was not overly sweet, which is good. Ton of basil and oregano flavor. Undercarriage was solid, literally no flop, which is surprising because the slice is heavy. Crust is the standout here — great crisp and cooked perfectly/evenly. 6.9. This same sauce and crust on a cheese slice would rate in the mid-to-high 7s. We’ll never know! The Sicilian was strong. Airy crust, more cheesy than saucy, a thick slice of pizza. Everything I look for in a Sicilian. A 7.3 on the Sicilian, so splitting the difference overall at a 7.1.
frank.reese1/29/21, 5:18 p.m.
Massive slices! Very greasy. Good crunch though. Zero flop. But could use some more sauce. Seems like yesterday’s slice.
mdz33901/16/21, 6:04 p.m.
I liked the corn meal on the crust. Got to love Arthur Ave in the Bronx
gmpizza12/30/20, 7:29 p.m.
Not to saucy but very greasy. But it hit the spot. Cheese has good flavor. Floppy first half with a bit of crisp
ecao9/27/20, 11:00 p.m.
Cheese pizza: good crunch, no flop, average crust; also very average cheese and sauce; good size though, but overall just a normal NY slice, nothing more nothing less
amordepizza4/21/20, 4:07 p.m.
This is a huge slice of pizza with a few issues. First issue is that the cheese and or sauce is salty. Good undercarriage, and the crust is solid and crispy... but having a salty slice is no bueno and that was my first impression on first bite.
mr.mozzerella3/19/20, 8:02 p.m.
Served quick and warm. Zero flop and the freshest sauce I’ve had in a while. There is no tang and the sauce tastes like unseasoned, cooked tomatoes. The mozzarella is above average with good flavor.the dough has good flavor but very little taste. The lack of cohesion really pulls the score down. This could touch the low 7’s if the sauce had a better taste and the slice wasn’t $3.75.
bob.abbate2/9/20, 6:40 p.m.
Had to stop in here, in honor of national pizza day. Typical New York pizza, nothing special. Greasy as hell. I feel like I have to go take a shower now.
l.madaus9/21/19, 11:22 p.m.
perfect slice after watching Fordham students pretend to like sports at howl or mugz. very greasy, but they gave me a slice and didn’t ask for money in return so, big plus from me.
scrapiron8/20/19, 6:29 p.m.
Standing in line and gringo (me) non bronx resident gets over looked employee completely disregarded me and helped someone else like I was a asshole just standing there.. Walked out like a doctor!! 0.0 professional score
brian13267/16/19, 9:07 p.m.
One bite sicilian slice. Solid Sicilian crust and sauce needs more flavor good pie overall
jacob.dicarlo7/13/19, 2:04 a.m.
So average it hurts. Make some better pizza my guys. Try harder. Please!
spencer.berson7/2/19, 10:24 p.m.
Really solid crisp. I love it except the sauce, not a huge fan of that. Other than that, cheese is good and crust is excellent too.
ruthlesslucius6/26/19, 1:05 a.m.
Perfect flop, tangy sauce, nice crisp to the crust. Not a bad slice