Top Restaurants

Gaeta's Tomato Pies

Gaeta's Tomato Pies

7616 Castor Avenue, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Pizza Review

1 like

ant-raff on One Bite Pizza App

ant-raff

7/2/22 5:50 PM

I am a big tomato pie fan with having 2 very good places near me !!! After, seeing ppl posting on FB the best tomato pie ever must had never had Corroplese or Conshy tomato pie !! This pie is no where in the same league. I was hugely disappointed with a zero crisp pure white soft undercarriage n they claim it is v crispy!!! I wasn't a fan of the sauce either.

Pizza Review

pete.mcd12/17/24, 9:07 a.m.

9.4

Pizza here is Phantastic I went crazy with the Toppings on this one, as I usually just order Traditional Round Plain Pizza Crust is crunchy, lite, and no flop Great coloring in the crust, aromatic and flavorful tomato with a great tasting, high quality cheese

Pizza Review

tomatobrypie12/9/23, 12:30 a.m.

9.8

On a PHILADELPHIA STYLE tomato pie scale, Gaeta’s is by far the best pie there is!!! Philadelphia style tomato pie is NOT pizza. This blows away all other Philadelphia style tomato pies.

Pizza Review

pizzabaron10/24/22, 1:16 p.m.

8.0

Might even be better than before with the new owners. Order it well done and they bake it perfectly. Sauce has a nice sweetness to it. 8.5 on the tomato pie scale for the normal tomato pie. I ordered this one “Trenton style” well done.

Pizza Review

subdiver9/3/22, 3:33 p.m.

7.2

Tomato pie with cheese on it, nothing too special but good with a crunchy bottom.

Pizza Review

mccannphilly5/29/22, 5:12 p.m.

9.1

9.1 on tomato pie scale. Haven't tried the pizza, but looks amazing. The tomato pie is a must have for any party or BBQ. Sauce is slightly acidic, crust is thin and very crispy. Perfect tomato pie. Will review pizza next time.

Pizza Review

maryann.winthrop3/14/20, 7:03 p.m.

8.1

I thought they only sold tomato pie but I was wrong. They have round pieces of heaven. Delish!

Pizza Review

drewkrivak10/17/19, 6:47 p.m.

8.1

Pizza Review

jbag.883/8/19, 6:12 p.m.

6.8

Yooooo Philly! Cool looking pie... sweet, sweet sauce which isn’t my favorite. The owner is a fun dude and this an authentic Italian bakery.

Pizza Review

mikeydeangelis11/7/18, 8:09 p.m.

8.5

Best tomato pie in the Philly area. Sauce is amazing and the pie is the perfect thickness. Highly recommend.