Sicilian isn’t my style…but the cheese and buttery crust on this was very notable
michael.stefanelli11/21/21, 2:47 p.m.
It's a good slice of pizza. However, may have been below expectations. Everything on top is good, crust and underneath felt soggy enough to detract a bit.
km01111/10/21, 1:44 p.m.
Dave must have lost his mind when he gave this place a 6.6 as it's the best Sicilian slice I've ever had! I lucked out with this one, as the person in front of me bought the rest of the slices, so they had to bring out a brand new fresh pie! I was able to get the corner slices without even getting a dirty look from the guy working the counter LOL The pie had a nice soft pillowy dough with a great crunch on the crust. Sauce and cheese were absolutely excellent as well and the flavor was unreal overall! It's going to be tough to find a sicilian slice that can top this, but eventually I'll make my way to Jackson New Jersey, to see if Brooklyn square can do it! Make sure you get there early, as the line was wrapped before noon, and as soon as this place sells out they close for the day.
nado8/25/21, 3:34 p.m.
Typically not a fan of Sicilian, this honestly blew me away. Slice is thin enough so Sicilian isn’t overdone, but still maintains the identity. Cheese is outstanding in flavor, tomato holds its own. Only negative is the crust wasn’t nearly as crunchy as a slice like this needed
joey.crail6/22/21, 5:55 a.m.
Favorite pizza of all time! So fresh, crust is to die for, sauce and cheese couldn’t be tastier.
pizzavampire6/10/21, 2:21 p.m.
Soft pillowy thin crust square slices made by two older guys rapping in Italian with the neighborhood locals. Very light for square cut. A fresh pan came out right as I walked in, and at $2 a pop, it was a wise decision I made to double down.
raphael.brathwaitejr10/24/20, 4:30 p.m.
I don’t know what Dave Portnoy was smoking but this pizza is amazing finally got to try it heard the hype about it been waiting to finally try it and exceeded my expectations cheese amazing sauce so flavorful and good buttery flavorful crust very amazed definitely in the nines and I stand by my score wow hands-down one of my new favorites 🍕 🙌🏾
justin.kwiatkowski19/17/20, 3:34 p.m.
Absolute delight. So happy the master is still making great quality pizza daily. Traditions matter.
rv8/20/20, 6:22 p.m.
Nothing that’s gonna blow you away. Far from the best pizza in the North End. Sauce is good, the slice could have been heated up a little before I got it. Won’t go out of my way for it.