Top Restaurants

Gappy's Pizza

1323 New York 52, Carmel Hamlet, New York

Pizza Review

2 likes

hvpizzaking on One Bite Pizza App

hvpizzaking

9/3/24 4:49 PM

Beautiful undercarriage with awesome leopard spots from the oven. Great crisp with zero flop from such a massive slice. Sauce could have used more seasoning, the cheese could have used a touch more salt, and it was a little too greasy. The ratios were spot on. Score could go higher, but still a good Putnam County slice.

Pizza Review

brooke.schwaiger7/17/23, 7:19 p.m.

9.0

best pizza when coming to Carmel

Pizza Review

mitch.gurevich12/29/22, 2:06 a.m.

6.7

Kinda tasteless pizza with just a hint of sweet sauce or dough. The scungilli marinara was actually pretty good and made it a worthwhile stop towards the end of a long road trip. Awful garlicky after taste though a few hours later

Pizza Review

dente4710/17/21, 1:28 a.m.

5.4

Soft dough, greasy

Pizza Review

richard.fasulo7/7/21, 10:12 p.m.

7.5

Pizza Review

apizzenzo1/24/20, 12:53 a.m.

6.2

Good Spot , underrated. Friendly staff

Pizza Review

pizzadinoguy12/10/19, 2:17 a.m.

6.5

Pizza Review

bgrest10/27/19, 5:48 p.m.

0.2

Pizza Review

shawn.tamboia10/15/19, 3:28 p.m.

6.8

Pizza Review

wiggidywhack7/14/19, 7:41 p.m.

6.2

Giant slice - needed to be cooked more. Flavor Flave would have rated this a 5.6 It’s all good. Maybe slices should be cut in 1/2 with a chainsaw cause them shitz is big. Put it up next to my size 13.5 sneaker and it had me beat like a race horse in the Kentucky Derby. Crust is thin maybe they shouldn’t play hoola hoop and spin it on their arm so damn long. Needed 3 hands to hold that slice. If it was Mexico they would name this pizza EL Monsteroso slice. Burnt my lips so bad it made my blue eyes brown . Sappening?

Pizza Review

jaydakidd4/13/19, 1:51 a.m.

6.5

Football pizza!! A Local spot, big flop No crisp. Great people but just an average slice.

Pizza Review

pizza_slut10/31/18, 1:32 a.m.

6.8

Football Pizza. Extra Heavy. Didn’t stop me from eating 3 slices

Pizza Review

rob.blenkle10/28/18, 10:30 p.m.

7.2

Good pizza, not great. Gappy’s is a hit or miss spot. This time was a very good slice. For the $13.55 all in price for a large cheese you can’t beat it. Must better than any chain, and a 7.2 on the NY scale

Pizza Review

john.schurmacher10/6/18, 9:19 p.m.

7.9

Got the New York flop. Crispy bottom and crust. Gooey cheese. Little oil. Hot🔥 burned my mouth a little had to let it cool down but it’s also fresh out of an oven so it’s my own fault.

Pizza Review

nick_viviano8/30/18, 2:47 a.m.

5.3

Needs more cheese. The definition of average.