Gargano's Pizzeria & Deli

Different. Good flavor, some flop, keep in the oven a minute longer

Chewy crust but good cheese and sauce

Nice structure, tasty crust, mild flop, generous amount of cheese and pepperoni, sauce to me lacked flavor.

As NY (Brooklyn) as it gets. Owner loves what he does and that’s what makes it that much better. If you’re from Brooklyn or NYC then this place is a must go to spot. Zero flop with a little crunch from every bite.

This is great pie. Only thing keeping it from being an 8+was it having too much cheese

First off, don't judge me on the Hawaiian pizza... but hands down, as far as local places go, this is the leadervof the pack. Joe has been doing pizza longer than I've been alive and it shows. Solid pie.

Asked for crispy, pie came out not crispy, cheese kinda fell right off the slice. Overall, above the local competition, been around since 78’ which is also impressive.

Good basic pizza. Good flavor, I like pizza thinner and crispier but I was pleased with this pizza. The staff is some of the friendliest people I’ve met at pizza places.

Really good pizza. One of best in area.

Best pizza in the area by far. From New York and have been to many of Dave’s top spots including John’s of bleeker. Respectable pie

Old school place and best slice in area!!

Good pizza, excellent cheese. The pizza wasn’t too floppy but the crust wasn’t crispy either. A crispier crust would put it over the top.

Worth stopping! Great sauce! Been here for 60+ years! Cash only!