Garlic New York Pizza Bar

Best pizza in Murray hill. Eggplant slice (right) was out of this world. So much flavor and texture on a thin and crispy base. Only reason it’s not 9+ is because the parmigiana slice (left) was pretty underwhelming. Been coming here since 2018 and love it

Very hot and greasy, gotta let it sit for a few mins but when it’s the right temp it’s exceptional

Mid pizza at best. Crust has no crunch. Sauce wasn’t robust. Cheese was a bit sour. Still ate 4 slices

Great crust and loved the variety. Honey pepperoni with pesto is a solid slice.

Noticed a ton of grease on the hood of my pizza box when I picked this up. It was thrown into the box like this. Pictured here is their Famous Grandma Pie. I don’t know what they expect me to do with this, don’t order whole pies here.

Not good

Best part about this pizza is that it's open. Dave gave this in the high 6's? Insane. Cheese/sauce is below average. Crisp is solid. Not great. Is what it is

Probably the most disappointing slice of the year for me. Sugary sweet, greasy, bad value. 2.2.

Sweet sauce. Sweet cheese. Very classic soccer pizza

Regular slice was a 5.9, very greasy. The grandma slices were bad, very greasy.

Sub par presentation...but red sauce and garlic crust deliver