Gencarelli's Restaurant

The Grandma Pie at Gencarelli's is one of the top pies I've ever had.......

My hometown spot I’ve been going since I was a kid with my parents and childhood friends. Really really good football pizza, quality ingredients.

Pizza you would never complain about, but also nothing really that stand out other than pep slice way to salty

Panko on the crust 👍🏼

Thin crust pepperoni - this place always is on point!

Pinebrooklyn pizza. Sweet sauce. Buttery crust and undercarriage. Very.

Good local spot.

Genc’s has always done me well so this is not a knock, just not my favorite as I venture along the pizza game. It looks like it would be amazing but it is lacking both within the cheese and the sauce. Very bread based and the bread is not that special. I feel like I’m even being a little biased with my rating based off my Montville home roots.

Best pizza around... cheese pie is the great but their Gencarelli’s special is outstanding! In the 9’s for sure!

A confusing slice. Very very floppy. The crust has a decent crunch. The bottom of the pizza is very thin and mostly doughy but has spots of crunch. The sauce is unique and the cheese is solid.

When I say this pizza has a flop, I mean an ugly fat chick with halitosis on top of whiskey dick type of flop. What they lack in flavor they make up for in corn starch on the bottom. Simple pizza, pretty light and won't make you want to lay in bed the rest of the day. Not bad, but nowhere near good. 6.1, max.

Okay pizza, sauce has little flavor, major flop factor and super greasy. Crust is fluffy(which is my preference), but is corn starchy and under done. Could be better, could be worse.

Amazing Grandma slice. Cheese slice is a 7.1

Stellar grandma slice