Geraldi's

Phenomenal pie. Geraldi’s always does it right. Flop action brings the score down a little. But one of if not the best pies you can get in Fayetteville

Got the Margherita pizza and it was absolutely delectable. Only reason I won’t be giving it an 8.0 is because the flop was bad. Cheesy, tasty, large, and 10/10 presentation. Best Margherita pizza I have ever had.

Great local pizza spot. Crust could be crispier, but the cheese is awesome and has that New York style vibe to it. They don’t overcharge you either

Good pizza. Best in Fayetteville so far.

Best pizza in town, everybody knows the rules. A pretty floppy pizza, sometimes a little too heavy on the cheese, but the sauce is impeccable and the crust is very crispy. If I could eat this every day and not become a McFatty I would.

Great place, loved the vibe. Pizza was good. Cheese and sauce both had good flavor. The crust was excellent. Was the pizza the best ever? Not necessarily. Could I still eat it ten times in a row? Most definitely. *THE PASTA IS A 9/10*

Ordered a cheese. Got a pepperoni. Greasy, but good.