Gino's Pizza of West Babylon

Gonna start off with fuck this place and its management. Placed a $100 order for 4 pizzas and a large salad. Get there, pick it up, all is good. Get home, open my order....1 missing the topping i paid extra for, and given a regular pie instead of the grandma. I call up to let them know what was going on, told they can correct the mistake with the pie, and could either be delivered or picked up. Told them to deliver since i had a house full of people. Gave them my address (4 miles away) and then am told they cant deliver, i have to pick up. Asked for management, denied. I told them i want a refund, told it has to go through uber since i placed the pickup order through them...basically to fuck myself. I go back, and the pussy manager decides to send the desk girl up because cant be bothered to deal with a customer who you know is pissed. Pizza is trash as well.

amazing. great sauce and a good crunch

This is definitely New York style. Heavy chew, crunchy end crust that wasn’t bustling with flavor. The sauce is better than most locally and the cheese is decent. The cold slice energy is low. To me, that’s what sets apart a good slice from a great slice, would I eat it cold? This thing flopped like a dead fish and the dough gave my jaw a workout like it was training for UFC 294. There’s 8 million pizzerias on this dump of an island, this one doesn’t stand out. I’ve had much worse, but I’ve had much better.

Best pizza around. Used to be in farmingdale. Good crisp. Little flop.

Decent slice, huge garlic knots